Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Faithful and Wrong - When Seeking God Doesn't Go the Way You Planned
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Faithful and Wrong - When Seeking God Doesn't Go the Way You Planned
FAITHFUL AND WRONG — WHEN SEEKING GOD DOESN'T GO THE WAY YOU PLANNED The Jake Giffin Podcast | Feat. Paul Granger
Most men have a version of faith that operates on expectation. They seek God sincerely, show up, stay faithful, and quietly assume that faithfulness produces a specific outcome. When it doesn't, the options are narrow: blame yourself, blame God, or quietly revise what you claimed to believe.
Paul Granger has spent two decades in inner-city ministry in Richmond, Virginia — living on donated income, raising a family in one of the city's toughest neighborhoods, asking one question every single day: where did you see God? He doesn't ask it as a spiritual warm-up exercise. He asks it because the honest answer exposes whether you were actually looking — or whether you were looking for a very specific thing and calling that seeking.
In this segment, the conversation gets uncomfortable. Not because the ideas are fragile. Because Paul is willing to follow them into the territory where they actually get tested — where faithful people do everything right and the outcome looks nothing like what they expected God to produce.
Peter is the case study. Peter, who had a front-row seat to three years of miracles. Who saw nature obey. Who walked on water until he started thinking about it. Who pulled a sword in the garden because he was ready for a blaze of glory — and then denied Christ three times before sunrise because the actual unfolding of God's plan bore no resemblance to his theology. Peter's framework wasn't wrong because he was weak. It failed because he was still operating from a human metric of what faithfulness is supposed to look like.
Jesus didn't have a perfect track record. Not by our metrics. He entered public ministry and died surrounded by fewer followers than he started with. His inner circle scattered. His most vocal defender denied him publicly. By every measurable standard, the conclusion is failure. What Paul confronts in this conversation is the discomfort of sitting with that observation — and why most men immediately explain it away rather than let it do its work.
Because most men do explain it away. They build theology that insulates them from the gap between what they believe and what they observe. And when the gap gets too wide — when the situation refuses to resolve, when the wilderness year becomes two, when the door they prayed open stays closed — the theology doesn't hold. What they're left with isn't a crisis of circumstance. It's a crisis of identity.
Proverbs 3:5-6 doesn't say trust God until it gets hard. It says trust with all your heart, do not lean on your own understanding, and in all your ways submit to him. Comprehensive, not seasonal. The steelman argument here is not that faith is irrational. It's that much of what men call faith is a transactional expectation with God's name on it. When the transaction doesn't close on their timeline, they either perform a crisis or perform a recovery — and neither is what Paul Granger is actually describing.
What he's describing is releasing your grip on what God does with your faithfulness. Not just seeking God. Seeking God and then trusting the outcome entirely to him — including outcomes that look, by every external measure, like failure.
That discipline is harder than the seeking. And this conversation doesn't soften it.
This is Segment 2 of a three-part interview. Segment 3 is where the value transfers. If you haven't seen Segment 1, start there.
Subscribe. Leave a review. Send this to one person who needs it. Every one of those actions matters to the mission and to the algorithm — and right now we need both.
JAKE GIFFIN — Author | Coach | Speaker | Host MADEMAN: The Blueprint — available at https://www.mademan.net Website: https://www.jakegiffin.com Instagram | Facebook | X | TikTok | YouTube | LinkedIn: @thejakegiffin
PAUL GRANGER — Author | Minister | Host, Where Did You See God? Podcast Paul Granger has served in inner-city ministry since 2005. Since 2008, he and his family have lived in the east end of Richmond, Virginia, on donated income, as part of Youth With A Mission Virginia. He is a husband, father of three, author of more than 24 books, and has a forthcoming title from Morgan James Publishing. His work centers on one question: where did you see God today? Website: https://www.wheredidyouseegod.com Instagram | Facebook: @wheredidyouseegod Books: https://amazon.com/author/paulgranger Podcast: Where Did You See God? — available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and all major platforms
Topics: seeking God in hard times | Christian faith and doubt | spiritual formation | biblical discipleship | Proverbs 3:5-6 | trust vs. expectation | Peter's denial | inner city ministry | Christian identity | God's silence | men and faith | biblical manhood | where did you see God | Paul Granger | The Jake Giffin Podcast
View all episodes
By Jake GiffinFAITHFUL AND WRONG — WHEN SEEKING GOD DOESN'T GO THE WAY YOU PLANNED The Jake Giffin Podcast | Feat. Paul Granger
Most men have a version of faith that operates on expectation. They seek God sincerely, show up, stay faithful, and quietly assume that faithfulness produces a specific outcome. When it doesn't, the options are narrow: blame yourself, blame God, or quietly revise what you claimed to believe.
Paul Granger has spent two decades in inner-city ministry in Richmond, Virginia — living on donated income, raising a family in one of the city's toughest neighborhoods, asking one question every single day: where did you see God? He doesn't ask it as a spiritual warm-up exercise. He asks it because the honest answer exposes whether you were actually looking — or whether you were looking for a very specific thing and calling that seeking.
In this segment, the conversation gets uncomfortable. Not because the ideas are fragile. Because Paul is willing to follow them into the territory where they actually get tested — where faithful people do everything right and the outcome looks nothing like what they expected God to produce.
Peter is the case study. Peter, who had a front-row seat to three years of miracles. Who saw nature obey. Who walked on water until he started thinking about it. Who pulled a sword in the garden because he was ready for a blaze of glory — and then denied Christ three times before sunrise because the actual unfolding of God's plan bore no resemblance to his theology. Peter's framework wasn't wrong because he was weak. It failed because he was still operating from a human metric of what faithfulness is supposed to look like.
Jesus didn't have a perfect track record. Not by our metrics. He entered public ministry and died surrounded by fewer followers than he started with. His inner circle scattered. His most vocal defender denied him publicly. By every measurable standard, the conclusion is failure. What Paul confronts in this conversation is the discomfort of sitting with that observation — and why most men immediately explain it away rather than let it do its work.
Because most men do explain it away. They build theology that insulates them from the gap between what they believe and what they observe. And when the gap gets too wide — when the situation refuses to resolve, when the wilderness year becomes two, when the door they prayed open stays closed — the theology doesn't hold. What they're left with isn't a crisis of circumstance. It's a crisis of identity.
Proverbs 3:5-6 doesn't say trust God until it gets hard. It says trust with all your heart, do not lean on your own understanding, and in all your ways submit to him. Comprehensive, not seasonal. The steelman argument here is not that faith is irrational. It's that much of what men call faith is a transactional expectation with God's name on it. When the transaction doesn't close on their timeline, they either perform a crisis or perform a recovery — and neither is what Paul Granger is actually describing.
What he's describing is releasing your grip on what God does with your faithfulness. Not just seeking God. Seeking God and then trusting the outcome entirely to him — including outcomes that look, by every external measure, like failure.
That discipline is harder than the seeking. And this conversation doesn't soften it.
This is Segment 2 of a three-part interview. Segment 3 is where the value transfers. If you haven't seen Segment 1, start there.
Subscribe. Leave a review. Send this to one person who needs it. Every one of those actions matters to the mission and to the algorithm — and right now we need both.
JAKE GIFFIN — Author | Coach | Speaker | Host MADEMAN: The Blueprint — available at https://www.mademan.net Website: https://www.jakegiffin.com Instagram | Facebook | X | TikTok | YouTube | LinkedIn: @thejakegiffin
PAUL GRANGER — Author | Minister | Host, Where Did You See God? Podcast Paul Granger has served in inner-city ministry since 2005. Since 2008, he and his family have lived in the east end of Richmond, Virginia, on donated income, as part of Youth With A Mission Virginia. He is a husband, father of three, author of more than 24 books, and has a forthcoming title from Morgan James Publishing. His work centers on one question: where did you see God today? Website: https://www.wheredidyouseegod.com Instagram | Facebook: @wheredidyouseegod Books: https://amazon.com/author/paulgranger Podcast: Where Did You See God? — available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and all major platforms
Topics: seeking God in hard times | Christian faith and doubt | spiritual formation | biblical discipleship | Proverbs 3:5-6 | trust vs. expectation | Peter's denial | inner city ministry | Christian identity | God's silence | men and faith | biblical manhood | where did you see God | Paul Granger | The Jake Giffin Podcast