The Challenge Historian

Fantasy Casting The Challenge All Stars Real World vs Road Rules


Listen Later

The next season of The Challenge All Stars should be Real World vs Road Rules and I won't hear otherwise! With All Stars Rivals being such a hit, and with Mark Long himself tweeting about it, my longtime desire for All Stars to do a Real World vs Road Rules team season resurfaced in a big way. It was the theme that started it all, and the options for casting are vast (and realistic)!

Today, I'm breaking down why I want RW vs RR so bad as the next All Stars theme, what the best case format would look like, and then doing not one, not two, not three, but FOUR different fantasy casts of RW vs RR teams that are all highly realistic to make happen.

Cold Open (00:00)

Why Real World vs Road Rules (00:50)

The Format (08:53)

As OG As Possible Cast (14:08)

Max Star Power Cast V1 (19:00)

Max Star Power Cast V2 (23:37)

Most Realistic Cast (29:12)

Other Names Worth Calling (31:16)

Tell Me Your Picks (34:54)

#TheChallenge #TheChallengeAllStars #TheChallengeAllStarsRivals #RealWorld #RoadRules #RealWorldvsRoadRules #WeWantOGs #TheChallengeHistorian #RealityTVRecap #RealityTVPodcast #TheChallengePodcast #TheChallengeRecaps 

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Challenge HistorianBy Jacob Hollabaugh

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

38 ratings


More shows like The Challenge Historian

View all
Rob Has a Podcast | Survivor, Big Brother & Reality TV by Survivor Know-It-All, Rob Cesternino | RHAP Productions

Rob Has a Podcast | Survivor, Big Brother & Reality TV

5,071 Listeners

RHAP: We Know Reality TV by Friends of Rob Has a Podcast

RHAP: We Know Reality TV

1,367 Listeners

The Challenge RHAP-up | Rob has a Podcast by Challenge Recaps from MTV Experts Brian Cohen and Ali Lasher

The Challenge RHAP-up | Rob has a Podcast

1,297 Listeners

Challenged: A Podcast About The Challenge on CBS, MTV, and Paramount+ by Bryan, Zach, Carlyn and Tim

Challenged: A Podcast About The Challenge on CBS, MTV, and Paramount+

673 Listeners

Challenge Mania by Challenge Mania

Challenge Mania

2,992 Listeners

The Right Reality Podcast | The Challenge All Stars | Tempation Island by The Right Reality

The Right Reality Podcast | The Challenge All Stars | Tempation Island

408 Listeners

The Challenge Chronicles by The Challenge Chronicles

The Challenge Chronicles

74 Listeners

The Challenge Fanatics by Chicago Style

The Challenge Fanatics

39 Listeners

The Challenge: Roundtable Reacts by Levi Hall

The Challenge: Roundtable Reacts

17 Listeners

MTV's Official Challenge Podcast by iHeartPodcasts and MTV Entertainment Studios

MTV's Official Challenge Podcast

2,494 Listeners

Caffeine Confessionals by Allan Aguirre, Luke Munsey, and Zoe Trimboli

Caffeine Confessionals

28 Listeners

The Ringer Reality TV Podcast by The Ringer

The Ringer Reality TV Podcast

1,017 Listeners

The Challenge Fandom Podcast by The Challenge Fandom Podcast

The Challenge Fandom Podcast

129 Listeners

The Zach Nichols Podcast by GOHT Media

The Zach Nichols Podcast

158 Listeners

The Free Agents Podcast: The Challenge, The Traitors, & more by Matt and Scally

The Free Agents Podcast: The Challenge, The Traitors, & more

141 Listeners