The six-star review madness has to stop. Rich and Ryan open this spoiler-free FastTake by calling out BookTok’s chaotic scoring habits before diving headfirst into Brandon Sanderson’s Wind and Truth, the long-awaited finale to Stormlight’s first arc.

It’s part rant, part celebration, and fully Hot Take Books energy. Rich compares the book to a Hall-of-Fame victory lap, Ryan swears it’s his most-highlighted read yet, and somewhere in there they debate whether a single jalapeño seed counts as “spice.”

They talk pacing, payoff, and why this series remains the cornerstone of the Cosmere—warts and all. Because Wind and Truth might not be perfect, but it’s bold, heartfelt, and ambitious as hell.

By the end, they land on the only comparison that feels right: this book is the chocolate-chip cookie of the Cosmere—warm, satisfying, and messy AF.