We could do a deep dive on any of these six films, but we want to give you just enough of a taste that you might be inclined to seek them out yourselves. We picked movies that aren’t necessarily blockbusters. Some have just gotten lost in the never-ending onslaught of newer films, some were popular overseas but not in America, and some just have nostalgia value.

Gordon's picks: Zulu (1964), Appaloosa (2008), Alatriste (2006)
Nancy's picks: A Very Long Engagement (2004), Conagher (1991), Gunga Din (1939)
Bonus mentions: Ride with the Devil, Joyeux Noel, Tombstone, They Shall Not Grow Old.