We’re about to break the first rule of Fight Club.

In this episode, we dive headfirst into David Fincher’s dark, stylish, and endlessly debated 1999 film based on Chuck Palahniuk’s debut novel. We talk about the brilliance of the voiceover, one of the greatest character intros of all time, and how Brad Pitt and Edward Norton pulled off one of cinema’s wildest twists.

But beyond the punches and soap-making, we ask the deeper questions: Is Fight Club to blame for toxic masculinity? Or is it a razor-sharp satire that’s been misunderstood for over two decades?