On the third episode of Movies I Missed: 2008, Jesse and Rian drown their sorrows in sunny beaches, fruity drinks with little umbrellas in them and a surprising amount of male nudity by reviewing Forgetting Sarah Marshall. Rian picked this film for the show because it was a popular comedy from the time that he was 100% positive he’d never seen before. Join our hosts as they marvel at an early assemblage of modern comedy greats, judge the logistics of the average low budget puppet musical and ponder if 40 is too young to suffer early onset memory loss.

WARNING: While the conceit of the show revolves around first-time watches, Movies I Missed contains hearty amounts of spoilers.