Happy Huluween! Instead of working on their marriage, former critics Alex and Logan dove headfirst into gory, spooky, killer pumpkin-y world of Huluween. As true former critics do, they found positive things to say about all three movies.

What horrors await? The dysfunctional couple checked out Carved, Abracadaver, and Mr. Crocket, all available on Hulu. Logan would have been satisfied seeing one of these in theaters—but which? Also, will Alex please STOP trying to turn this into a The Substance episode?!

Happy Huluween, Tubiween, and/or Mubiween to all who celebrate!