Author’s note: This essay is about hell, but not really. It is about what happens when knowledge becomes armor.

We were drinking frozen margaritas.

She had invited her friend over, so it was two of them and one of me. Cold glasses sweating on the table. Something easy playing. The kind of night that does not announce what it is about to be.

I had been in the city about a week. I knew almost nobody. My life was in boxes at my brother’s place, and I was still learning the trains. When you are that new somewhere, every room you sit in is a room you are asking permission to stay in.

Her friend was not just a friend. They called each other sisters, which is different. There are friends you laugh with, and there are friends who feel responsible for what happens to you after the laughing is over. She was around our age, close enough to know charm does not prove character, and close enough to her to ask the question out loud.

You a God-fearing man?

I told them the truth, which is that I used to be a pastor. Seventeen years. Youth leader, touring musician, Bible college, seminary, the pulpit, all of it. I said it plain.

The friend said okay, like she was filing it somewhere. Then she leaned in.

Just tell me you’re not an atheist. You believe in heaven and hell, don’t you.

Here is the first thing they ever taught me: whatever you believe, understand why you believe it.

That was the whole discipline. That was the love, even. Do not hold a thing you cannot defend. So I went looking. Concordances. Translations laid side by side. Study Bibles with the margins full. Apologetics, which is a churchy word for learning how to win. I sat in rooms full of other believers and argued for hours about the most loving way to hold a hard doctrine. I got good at it. Better than good.

They had a verse for it. Rightly dividing the word of truth. To know the word and cut it clean and hand a person the right piece at the right time. That was holy. That made you useful. That made you dangerous in the right way. That made you a man worth keeping around.

I was twelve the first time it paid.

We had a Bible memorization competition, and I won it. Then I kept winning it. I could hold the verses the other kids fumbled, chapter and reference, clean off the top. The youth pastor watched me do it, and his face changed. Then he said the thing.

One day that’s gonna be you. You’re gonna run this youth group when you grow up.

My father had been gone two years.

So when a grown man put his hand on my shoulder and told me I was going to be somebody, I did not hear a calling. I heard a man who might stay. For the first time since my father left, who I was meant something, and the thing that made it mean something was the word. Knowing it. Holding it. Being the one who could.

I had already learned that staying was not free. You earned it. So I learned the verses. All of them. A boy will do anything that makes a man look at him like that.

Nobody told me what that command would do if you actually obeyed it. A man trained to ask why he believes will one day ask it about the belief itself. They put the knife in my hand for the faith. I turned the same knife on the faith. They planted the seed of my leaving and called the seed obedience.

So when her sister-friend leaned in over the frozen margaritas and asked me to confirm the fire, here is what I did.

I told her I don’t believe in hell.

And then I could not leave it there.

I gave her Sheol: the grave, the pit, the place everybody goes, good and bad, no flame in it at all. I gave her Gehenna: the valley outside Jerusalem where they burned the trash, a real place with a real smell, turned into metaphor and then hardened into doctrine. I gave her Hades, borrowed from the Greeks. I gave her the lake of fire out of a book of visions nobody reads straight.

Four versions. Where each one came from. What got translated. What got flattened. What got preached until it sounded older than it was.

To a woman who wanted one hell, I handed her four and a reading list. I out-theologied her at her own table. I built a podium out of frozen margaritas and stood behind it.

Halfway through, I knew I was doing too much. I could feel the room change. I was not answering her anymore. I was taking apart a theology she may have received through family, grief, songs, funerals, mothers, aunties, and Sunday mornings. I had spent years training for an argument she had not come there to have. She had asked me if I had a center. I showed her I had weapons.

But it was not just any table.

The church is one of the things that carried us. When my people had nothing, they had a Sunday. They prayed their way through what was built to bury them. The freedom songs came out of that room. The marching came out of that room. The mothers and grandmothers and aunties who kept families alive came out of that room with peppermints in their purses and scripture in their mouths.

So when a Black woman asks me if I am God-fearing, she is not always being nosy. And this woman especially was not being nosy. She was her sister in the way Black women sometimes mean sister: chosen, protective, close enough to ask the question nobody else wants to ask. She was not trying to win a debate. She was trying to see if the man at the table had a center.

That should have changed how I answered.

It did not.

I knew what my no might sound like in a room like that. Not like a private conclusion. Like distance. Like danger. Like I had become too educated to still be held by the people who raised me. So I owed her honesty without conquest.

But watch what I actually did.

I did not answer. I preached.

That is the thing I keep having to learn about myself. I walked out of the building and kept the pulpit. When she reached for my center, I reached for the lectern, because the church did not only teach me doctrine. It taught me to never let a true thing stand there naked and cost what it costs. You frame it. You defend it. You witness.

The four versions of hell were not knowledge. They were armor. A man can get cut for being a heathen. He cannot get cut for being smart. So I traded the exposed man for the expert and let the expert do the talking. I gave testimony for my unbelief in the exact cadence they trained into me.

Same machine. New gospel.

And here is the part I cannot wave off: the fluency is real. I am not faking the four versions. I know them. I know them because of who I used to be, which means the truest thing about me is also the wall I hide behind. The rigor they grew in me is the cage I live in now. Nobody beat this into me. They praised it into me. Good is the part that does not wash off.

I am the best student in a school I dropped out of.

It is the same flinch every time. I can say the true thing. I cannot say it short. I cannot say it and stop. The quiet that comes after a naked sentence is the part that costs, and I have never once let it cost. I fill it. With context. With origins. With nuance. With the most loving way to hold the doctrine. I have been filling that silence my whole life.

So picture me at the table. Frozen margarita going to water. Four versions deep. The most fluent man in the room, speaking a language I renounced, standing behind a podium nobody asked me to build.

And she still could not see me. Not because she lacked the eyes. Because I had stacked a wall of Hebrew and Greek between her and the one thing I walked in carrying.

The truth was never four versions.

The truth was four words.

I don’t believe in hell.

There it is.

I’m not going to explain it this time.

Get full access to Amen. Aśe. And All That S**t. at amenaseandall.substack.com/subscribe