
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Even before he had sent out the letter not even ten days prior Lieutenant Colonel William Barret Travis knew that the cause had been lost. Even as the 187 volunteers who stood guard within the mission walls looked out on the sea of 3,000 Mexican soldiers under the command of the Napoleon of the West, General Antioni López de Santa Anna, they knew how outnumbered they truly were.
In their minds this was not how it was meant to be, and there was little doubt they had wondered how it had carried this far. Mexico was supposed to be a land of opportunity for them. It had only declared its independence from Spain 4 years prior when Americans began to immigrate. The Panic of 1819 had led to financial disaster as depression gripped the economy and land prices soared. The Second Bank of the United States, and, in turn, the government had failed the people as the inflationary bubble ballooned out of control, until it finally burst. Mexico, despite the political instability, seemed like it was the new frontier with its vast open territory in Texas, and its new federalist system modeled after the United States
Yet it wouldn’t last…
In 1833 Santa Anna would be swept to power, and he would begin to test the scope of that authority. Within two years the fight between the President’s new Centralist Agenda, and the established Federalist order that had dominated the Mexican way of life for the past decade would turn to violence. It wasn’t just Texas that rebelled. Several states openly defied the regime that exerted its dominance over them. Yet one by one they fell to the Army of Operations as Santa Anna stepped down to lead the army and put down the insurrection. Even the well-armed Zacatecan Army under Governor Francisco García Salinas fell within two hours as 3,000 of his citizens were taken prisoner. It would be the last stand before the Constitution of 1824 was replaced by the Seven Laws. Mexico would dissolve the Congress and consolidate its power in the hands of the President, becoming a dictatorship.
Now, the Alamo was next in front of Santa Anna…
His troops had already been forced to withdraw at the Battle of Gonzales, humiliated during the Gulf Coast Campaign and defeated at the Siege of Bexar. Each step of the way they would be frustrated by the Texians. But there would be no salvation for the rebels locked behind those mission walls. Colonel Travis knew it as well. Having only been sent to the Alamo a month prior and having been given joint command with Colonel James Bowie, he had sent his famous plea just a few days prior, declaring, “ The enemy has demanded a surrender at discretion, otherwise, the garrison are to be put to the sword, if the fort is taken - I have answered the demand with a cannon shot, & our flag still waves proudly from the walls - I shall never surrender or retreat. Then, I call on you in the name of Liberty, of patriotism & everything dear to the American character, to come to our aid, with all dispatch - The enemy is receiving reinforcements daily & will no doubt increase to three or four thousand in four or five days. If this call is neglected, I am determined to sustain myself as long as possible & die like a soldier who never forgets what is due to his own honor & that of his country - Victory or Death.” Perhaps had Bowie removed the artillery and destroyed the fortification, having had the authority from Major General Sam Houston, but it was too late now
No real relief would come. Colonel James Fannin would march his troops, some three hundred strong, but they would push only to Goliad before trouble would greet them, leaving them stuck without food or adequate supplies. Washington was too far for Travis to reach the ears of the American President to send help and support, not with the numbers massing outside those walls.
At 5:30am on March 6th 1836 the Mexican Army would begin their advance. Sleep deprived and exhausted, three sentinels would be found sleeping, and killed before they could sound the alarm. It wouldn’t be until the sound of the bugle and the cries of “Viva Santa Anna!" that the defenders would know that the siege was upon them. The women and children would hastily rush to the chapel, barricading themselves in. From the other side, Travis would yell, “Come on boys, the Mexicans are upon us and we'll give them hell!” as they rushed forward to meet the flood of troops that came crashing down on them. He would be one of the first to fall, shot firing into the invading forces rank, drawing his sword, taking a soldier who had scaled the wall with him.
Within an hour the battle would be over. Colonel Bowie would be dead on his cot, too sick to meet the invaders on at the wall, but braced against the wall with pistols and his infamous knife. Stories would circulate that Colonel Davey Crockett would be found with at least 16 enemy soldiers fallen around his corpse. Major Robert Evans would fall with a torch in his hand, trying to set the gunpowder on fire. Had he not the blast would have encompassed the church. Among the last to fall Captain Almaron Dickinson, Second Lieutenant James Bonham, Colonel Travis’ cousin, and Private Gregorio Esparza grabbed rifles and started to fire before being overtaken by the bayonet, the last words escaping Dickinson’s mouth crying out, “Great God, Sue, the Mexicans are inside our walls! If they spare you, save my child”. In the end, when the smoke settled, all but seven of the defenders of the Alamo had died. As Santa Anna’s troops toured the carnage there would be no mercy shown, no reprieve offered. Any found moving would be bayoneted. Even the seven who surrendered would find no pity in the eyes of the enemy as he ordered their immediate execution. Yet, it would be a costly victory. For the almost 200 who would die 600 Mexican soldiers would be wounded or killed at the Alamo.
Though Santa Anna would press forward amidst the Goliad campaign, the Alamo would be a rallying cry for the Texas revolutionaries as he met his decisive defeat at the Battle of San Jacinto. Perhaps best described by the memorial at the field where General Houston’s forces took Santa Anna prisoner, it simply reads, “With the battle cry, "Remember the Alamo! Remember Goliad!" the Texans charged. The enemy taken by surprise, rallied for a few minutes then fled in disorder. The Texans had asked no quarter and gave none. The slaughter was appalling, victory complete, and Texas free! On the following day General Antonio Lopez De Santa Anna, self-styled "Napoleon of the West," received from a generous foe the mercy he had denied Travis at the Alamo and Fannin at Goliad.”
Monfort Browne, Lieutenant Governor of the Bahamas, was still dressed in his nightshirt when he rushed from Government House to order the alarm sound. The cannons would ring in the air, alerting the militia of the imminent attack. The American fleet had been spotted off of the coast of Nassau and it was only a matter of time now before the raid commenced.
The sound in the distance would be a disappointment to Commodore Esek Hopkins. He had ignored orders. Told by the Continental Congress to patrol the shores of Virginia, and North and South Carolina, conducting raids on British forces spotted off their coasts, he chose instead to set sail for Nassau. It was no secret that John Murray, Lord Dunmore, the Colonial Governor of Virginia, had ordered the removal of British stockpiles of weapons and gunpowder, sending them to New Providence in the Bahamas to keep these stores from being captured by Colonial Rebels. Now Dunmore was using those weapons to launch his own assaults, particularly off the coast of Virginia. Dangerously low on munitions, the Continental Congress planned a raid on Nassau but Hopkins orders, at least his known orders, didn’t include sailing further than Abaco. Now, with over 200 Continental Marines under the command of Samuel Nicholas, Captain of the Marines, his fleet anchored offshore planning their next move, knowing that it had to be a careful one. Familiar enough with the government seat, he knew that a dangerous bar lay just off from the entrance to the harbor. At the west Fort Nassau, though perpetually in disrepair, and at the east Fort Montague protected the opening. Gale force winds had already separated the Fly and the Hornet from the remainder of the fleet, sending the Hornet back to port for repairs. Though two British merchant ships would be captured on their way to Nassau and pressed into service, he still relied on the idea that this was to be a surprise attack. Those plans now had fallen to the wayside and the first attempt at an assault would be quickly aborted.
Yet Hopkins would not be so easily deterred. Planning a new attack from the east he would dispatch Captain Nicholas and his Marines as the Wasp and the Providence covered their landing.
At approximately 12:00pm on March 3rd, 1776 the United States Continental Marines lead by Captain Nicholas, accompanied by 50 sailors under the command of Lieutenant Thomas Weaver of the Cabot would come ashore at the east near Fort Montague. Barely four months old, it would be the first amphibious landing of the US Marine Corp. The British cannons would open fire, but it would only be a slight resistance. Even as Governor Browne arrived with an additional 80 militiamen they were severely outnumbered, perhaps more than Browne had initially imagined, because he would almost immediately order the withdrawal of troops from Montague, yielding the ground to the Marines. Resolved to the fate that he had lost the moment those troops took to the shore, the militia would return home rather than mount a resistance, and Browne himself would retire to Government House to plan his next move.
Here Commodore Hopkins would make his strategic blunder. As Nicholas took the evening to chart his course for the next day, as he took the time to strategically plan his next move with his troops, Browne would order over three quarters of the gun powder, 162 of the 200 barrels stockpiled, be loaded on the Mississippi Packet and the HMS St. John and sent to St. Augustine. Anchored off Hanover Sound, Hopkins had neglected to station any ships to guard Nassau Harbor. Though the fleet might then have been safely out of range of the British guns, the majority of the gunpowder desperately needed by General George Washington made its way from their hands, slipping just out of their grasp as, without trouble or incident, those ships set sail.
Regardless, the next day, as Captain Nicholas marched on Fort Nassau, he would do so without a shot fired. Having received word that, at most 200 militia, inhabitants of the town, constituted the only defense Hopkins penned an open letter declaring “The reasons of my landing an armed force on the island is in order to take possession of the powder and warlike stores belonging to the Crown and if I am not opposed in putting my design in execution the persons and property of the inhabitants shall be safe. Neither shall they be suffered to be hurt in case they make no resistance.” Taken at his word, the response was telling. As Nicholas approached the town he was met by resident. They were ready to surrender, abandoning the Nassau and the Governor to the Americans.
Once it had been discovered that Browne had successfully denied the American’s those desperately needed barrels of gunpowder, he would put in irons. Arrested, he was confined to the brig of Hopkins flagship the Alfred. Yet when the Commodore would return to America with the 30 plus barrels he could take hold off, as well as the 103 cannons and other munitions, it would not be Browne who would take the brunt of the blame, but the American commander himself.
Though initially praised for the attack he would eventually be court martialed. It would be the first disgrace in a downward spiral that would see to it that he was eventually forced from the Navy two years later. Browne would be, likewise, treated with scorn once he was traded back to the British for General William Alexander, captured during the Battle of Long Island. His actions and motives for those actions would be perpetually questioned by British Circles and in British Court. Captain Nicholas, commended for his actions, would be promoted to Major. Eventually he would be placed in a role similar to that of later Commandant of the Marines, his heart would be elsewhere. Seeking once more to be put back in the field he would be frustrated, finding that the Continental Congress had other designs for him. He would serve until the Continental Marines were disbanded at the end of the Revolution.
The Inauguration of the 19th President was but three days away. The problem was that though the election had been held four month prior, there was little telling who that would have been. New York Governor Samuel Tilden had won the popular vote by over 280,000, he had a clear majority of 50.9% to Ohio Governor Rutherford B. Hayes 47.9%. What’s more is he had to believe that he had edged out his Republican opponent in the Electoral College. He had taken 184 seats, one shy of the majority he needed to be sworn in, compared to Haye’s 165. With 19 out of the 20 electors in question being from the South, Tilden had to believe that he could manage to pick up 1 state before his opponent in that bitterly fought race would take all 20. After all, even if Hayes did take those three states, which seemed unlikely, Oregon Governor LaFayette Grover had given him the vote he needed when he replaced a Republican Elector John Watts with Democrat C.A. Cronin.
The truth was that the Democrats had every right to believe that they would win the election. Having had been in political exile since earliest of days of the Civil War, the Panic of 1873 had given them their opening. The next year they would make significant gains in the Senate, but more importantly, for the first time since 1860 they would take the House. By 1876 corruption, scandal and a lagging economy so plagued the Republican Party that many in the party feared that President Ulysses S. Grant would run for a third term, and there was nothing they could do about it. Though the legendary General, having seen his once golden reputation now tarnished by the political arena, would step down, the emergence of the virtually unknown Rutherford B. Hayes as the conventions dark horse, had all but handed the election to Tilden. Had not the charismatic Senator James G. Blaine of Maine not been embroiled in scandal they might have stood a chance. Instead they were straddled with a compromise on the 7th ballot as the Governor who placed 5th on the first two ballots became their candidate.
Even as the election turned dirty, even as his opponents tried to tar him as briber, thief and drunken syphilitic Tilden was the man who had gone against the political machine. He was the great reformer who had sent Boss Bill Tweed to prison. No amount of “Waving the Bloody Shirt” was going to distract from the fact that Tilden was the only man to clean up the mess of the previous Republican Administration. Though there was allegations of fraud and intimidation, with South Carolina, for example, reporting 101% voter turnout of all eligible voters while African-American votes more likely to be Republican than Democrat were suppressed, it was a bump in the road. He had little doubt that the newly appointed 15 Member Election Commission, selected by Congress to resolve the issue when the College could not name a clear winner, would undoubtedly give him the final legitimacy he needed.
It would take until March 2nd, 1877 but finally it had been decided by the 8 Republicans and 7 Democrats who comprised the Commission. Though Associate Justice Joseph P. Bradley, a Republican, had indicated that he would vote to award Florida to Tilden the night before, the end vote would be right along party lines, and, without a majority of both the House and Senate, it was finalized. As he travelled to Washington by train, Rutherford B. Hayes was informed that he had secured the 20 electoral seats necessary to defeat Governor Tilden by a single vote in the College. By the narrowest of majorities, the election had been decided with Louisiana, South Carolina, Florida, and that third vote from Oregon going to Hayes to give him a single seat edge over the more popular Tilden. For the first time in history the nation would have a President who lost the popular vote but won the Electoral College.
The Democrat controlled House would filibuster to prevent the results from becoming official, knowing that it needed to be finalized by the 4th or interregnum would occur as the normal functions of government would be suspended. It would take the compromise of 1877 to eventually resolve the issue, with Hayes agreeing to appoint a Democrat as the Post-Master General, and to remove all Federal Troops from Government Buildings in Louisiana, Florida and South Carolina, ending Reconstruction. Though Republicans would celebrate, with papers like the New York Times declaring, “Indeed, some of them go so far as to say that no matter what may come, the country is well rid of the pretender Tilden. For that person no one has a good word.” many Democrats would not, dubbing Hayes as “His Fraudulency” and “The Usurper”. In many senses he would never be their President. Four years later he would not subject himself to another election, reaffirming his commitment to a single term as he stepped aside for James Garfield. Tilden would go to the grave in 1886 believing he had been robbed what was rightfully his by the “Boss Thief”, declaring, “ I can retire to public life with the consciousness that I shall receive from posterity the credit of having been elected to the highest position in the gift of the people without any of the cares and responsibilities of the office.”
Prime Ministers didn’t last long as one administration quickly gave way to another. Since the Ministry of Henry Pelham ended under the reign of George II in 1754, Great Britain had seen seven men, and eight administrations holding office for no more than two to three years apiece. That was until the rise of Frederick North as he ascended to the First Ministry
For twelve years, twelve long years, with the full support and consent of George III, he would preside over the most powerful Empire of the world. Yet there was little doubt that time had taken its toll, aging the 49 year old perhaps the full measure of a lifetime in little over a decade. Even before his rise the American situation was beginning to steam. Within his first three month in office it would boil over. Within 6 years protests had turn to violence, violence to open defiance, and defiance to revolution as the American colonies asserted their Independence from the Court of Saint James. Perhaps, at times, he knew he was in over his head. Even as he declared the colonies in a state of rebellion in 1775, following Bunker Hill, he had sought to resign in favor of a Prime Minister who perhaps more experience in handling these affairs. In 1776, following the Battle of Saratoga, he would once more attempt to offer his resignation. The next year, as France entered the war, he would try again. In fact, on numerous occasions he had sought to set aside his own ambition, and alleviate his burden for someone he believed more apt and able, and each time the George III refused.
Yet, resignation would come. It just not in the form that he had perhaps hoped as he was marked as the man who lost the war.
By February 27th, 1782, it would become clear that the end was now near for not only Lord North but also the Revolution that had come to define so much of his administration. Even as word of the fall of Yorktown reached him, he would confide in his diary, “Oh God! It's all over.” Now General Henry Seymour Conway was rising to the floor of the House of Commons. Despite his majority in Parliament, the hold that Lord North had was beginning to crack as defections from his Tory’s strengthened the Whig Opposition. Five days earlier Conway had tried to end the War. He would fail by one vote. Now, with his resolution reworked, and reworded, 234 would vote for it, 215 would vote against. With a 19 vote majority a motion would pass to recognize America’s Independence and begin the peace process. Deserted, abandoned by many in his party, not just those who voted for the measure, but also by those who chose rather to be absent than vote for or against, it would be only the second time in the history of the Westminster System that a government had lost a vote of no-confidence. A few days later the papers would declare, “In consequence of this important decision, the nation are at last within the prospect of enjoying the blessings of a Peace with America.“ Having faced not just the American Revolution, but the Falkland Crisis against Spain, the Gordon Riots in Ireland, the potential invasion of the Isle of Wight and Portsmouth, and the prospect of losing Gibraltar, North couldn’t hold on anymore, nor lead the pro-War cause. But then it wasn’t as if he wished to either.
Within the next few weeks he would tender his resignation to George III. It would, despite it all, be with hesitation and reluctance that the King would accept. The Marques of Rockingham, after almost 16 years out of power, would be asked to lead despite the disdain the monarch felt towards him. Within less than half a year though Rockingham would be dead at age 52 from the flu. Despite the instability that would arise from the three Whig Prime Ministers who would take to the office between the resignation of Lord North and the rise of William Pitt the Younger in 1783, peace for the former American colonies would be secured at the Treaty of Paris, the lasting legacy of the almost ten months that William Petty, the Earl of Shelburne, spent as Prime Minister.
Is the Travel Ban issued by President Trump actually unconstitutional? Does it overstep the authority and the power that has been given to the President? In this episode of Fragile Freedom host Wyatt McIntyre takes on the question of the Trump Travel Ban that has been all over the news, taking a trip through time to discuss what power the President has in setting immigration policy and what power the judiciary has in reviewing those policies.
Starting with the Alien and Sedition Acts he moves through the Chinese Exclusion Act and the Johnson-Reed Act straight through to measures issued by President's Jimmy Carter, George W. Bush and Barack Obama to see what previous Administrations were allowed. From there he looks at decisions rendered in the Chae Chan Ping v. United States, United States v. Ju Toy, and Harisiades v. Shaughnessy to determine what the courts have said in the past regarding their power with regards to Judicial Review of Immigration Policy. With these cases in hand he works through the precedents and the legislation to answer the deeper questions people may have as to what is actually within the President's power and what is not when it comes to issuing a exclusionary immigration policies.
So take the time to join us for this controversial but must listen episode of Fragile Freedom.
When Massachusetts Senator Daniel Webster was offered the Vice Presidency on the Whig ticket of 1840 he declared, “I do not propose to be buried until I am really dead.” It was, as the nation’s first Vice President, John Adams described, largely viewed as “the most insignificant office that ever the invention of man contrived or his imagination conceived.” It was not an office often marred with controversy or struggle, at least not like the Presidency, whose elections had, more often than not, turned into brutal political blood sports. Then there was the man who became the only Vice President in history to be selected by the provisions of the Twelfth Amendment, as the Senate met on February 8th, 1837 to elect Richard Mentor Johnson as the 9th Vice President of the United State.
The truth was that Colonel Johnson, Congressman from Kentucky, was not Martin Van Buren’s first choice. He wasn’t Van Buren’s choice at all He wanted Virginia Congressman William Cabell Rives, a man who had begun his career studying law at Monticello under then former President Thomas Jefferson. But Rives, a onetime supporter of President Andrew Jackson, began to make an enemy of the President as he began to oppose the administration on hard money currency and its stance on state banks. While it left Jackson’s Vice President undeterred as he looked for his running mate for 1836, Jackson would start looking elsewhere before setting his sights on his protégé, Richard Johnson. Still, he was a hard choice and an even tougher sell. After all Johnson carried far too much baggage for his liking. Having been in a common-law marriage with a slave, Julia Chinn, he had lost his bid for re-election to the Senate less than a decade prior when he claimed their daughter as his own, offering to her his last name. To have an affair with a slave was acceptable, to introduce them and the children through them into society as one’s family was indefensible. Yet to Johnson there was no shame or embarrassment. As he explained it, “Unlike Jefferson, Clay, Poindexter and others I married my wife under the eyes of God, and apparently He has found no objections.” Even after her death just a few years prior he was a controversial choice, though he still seemed to keep his eye on a potential ascendency to the highest office of the land.
Regardless, Jackson believed that Johnson’s war record during the War of 1812, would offset any liability that he had, and offer credibility to Van Buren, who had not served. He was, after all, the hero of the Battle of the Thames, the man who had killed the Shawnee leader of the great Native American Confederacy, Tecumseh. In fact that would be all that he would run on as he took the line from Boston Publisher William Emmon’s poem as his slogan, “Rumpsey Dumpsey, Rumpsey Dumpsey, Colonel Johnson killed Tecumseh.” Yet it was not enough. Tennessee Supreme Court Justice John Catron, who would be appointed as an Associate Justice to the Supreme Court by Jackson during his final days in the White House as the court expanded from 7 members to 9, would declare to the President that he found the idea was ridiculous that “a lucky random shot, even if it did hit Tecumseh, qualifies a man for the vice presidency.”
In the end, the Electoral College agreed. South Carolina would, for the only time in its history, award its Electors to a Whig. It would return to the Democratic fold for every election after until 1868. Though Van Buren and Johnson carried the election with 15 states and 170 votes in the Electoral College compared to William Henry Harrison’s 7 states and 73 Electors, Virginia, a state that they won, refused to cast its 23 votes for Johnson as Vice President even as it affirmed Van Buren as the President. With 148 votes necessary, the faithless electors of that state had left him one vote shy. It was up to the Senate to decide by the power vested in them by the Constitution, which declared, “The person having the greatest number of votes as Vice-President, shall be the Vice-President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of Electors appointed, and if no person have a majority, then from the two highest numbers on the list, the Senate shall choose the Vice-President; a quorum for the purpose shall consist of two-thirds of the whole number of Senators, and a majority of the whole number shall be necessary to a choice.” They would have to pick between Johnson and Whig Vice Presidential Candidate Francis Grainger.
Johnson would carry the Senate 33 to 16, but it would be clearly across Party lines, with the clear majority of his votes coming from Jacksonian Democrats, with the Whigs casting their vote overwhelmingly for Grainger. Four years later though even Jackson couldn’t, and wouldn’t, save him. Viewed as a liability on the ticket Van Buren would opt not to have a running mate rather than the Vice President from Kentucky that couldn’t carry his own state, agreeing to a compromise that would see no one nominated to the ticket, allowing anyone to run as Vice President, allowing the States to decide. Johnson would run again, but perhaps as a incoherent shell of an embattled man desperate to retain the office that had, in that election, been spurned by Daniel Webster, when William Henry Harrison offered him the second spot on his ticket. With only 48 electoral votes, he would fall 12 short of the 60 that his one time running mate one. In the end it wouldn’t matter for either of them as Harrison won in a landslide, his short lived Presidency making way for John Tyler to ascend to the Presidency.
It was Thomas Jefferson who lamented that slavery would ultimately be the “rock upon which the old Union would split."
Now the hammer had come down, and it came down hard. Already six states, South Carolina, Alabama, Mississippi, Florida, Louisiana and Georgia, declared themselves to be free and sovereign states, separating themselves from the Union. Even as pamphlets with titles like “The South Alone Should Govern the South” circulated radical elements wove their way through Southern society to take hold, rejecting any form of compromise. Despite the efforts of its Governor, Sam Houston, a Constitutional Unionist, the Legislature reaffirmed the Texas Secessionist Convention. Voting with the six states that had already left, all that was needed now were the results of a referendum later that month. Yet none who left, or who were looking to leave had any intention of standing alone. Even before Abraham Lincoln would be sworn in as the 16th President of the United States, they would have a Republic of their own, one that would not be dominated by free states, one that would preserve for them the institution and foundations of their prosperity: slavery.
On February 4th, 1861 that new union would take form as delegates met in the small, unpaved frontier town of Montgomery, Alabama with the express “purpose of consulting with each other as to the most effectual mode of securing concerted and harmonious action in whatever measures may be deemed most desirable for our common peace and security.” Six states, with the advice of Texas, which soon would become the seventh, would form the provisional government of the Confederate States of America. Within five short days former United States Secretary of War and Senator from Mississippi, Jefferson Davies would be elected as their first, and ultimately only, President, though only Provisionally at this point, as ‘The Orator of Secession’ William Yancey handed the reigns of the new Revolution to him, declaring, “The man and the hour have met. We now hope that prosperity, honor, and victory await his administration.” Yet, for whatever might have been said as they perhaps convinced themselves that they were Patriots, no different than George Washington or Thomas Jefferson or James Madison, seeking to protect what was theirs from an overbearing, far distant Government that sought to rob from them their power and their property in the Union Alexander Stephens perhaps offered the strongest view of what this new government was founded upon.
A man who had been considered a moderate voice, and who sought to remind the South that though the Republicans controlled the White House Congress was controlled by the Democrats, he would be elected to the Confederate Congress before being selected as the first Vice President of the C.S.A. Contending that Thomas Jefferson was wrong in the Declaration of Independence when he wrote “ that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” he would inform an audience in Savannah, Georgia not even a month later, “Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth. This truth has been slow in the process of its development, like all other truths in the various departments of science.”
Whatever the cause or the case might have been to meet it, to rise to it they took the democratic tradition of the peaceful transition of power that had been a hallmark of the American Republic since the first election and destroyed it. They did so for the sole reason that they did not approve of the results of the election a few months prior. They would not wait and see, they would not seek compromise, they would not give this new President even a moments reprieve, fearing what he might do with his new Executive Power. Instead, they would fire on Federal troops, the would chase vessels carrying supplies to military facilities, but even louder than that they would proclaim they were no longer bound by the Constitution of the United States.
By mid April the Confederates would begin their bombardment of Fort Sumter. Three days later President Lincoln would call-up troops in response as the cry for war sounded through the streets of the North and the South. The Civil War, that long and bloodied struggle that would claim the lives of more 650,000 Americans, would be upon us.
Secession was “a right unknown in the Constitution”, one that, without doubt or question, would ultimately lead to “anarchy and war”, at least that would be what James G. Taliaferro, Delegate to the Louisiana Secessionist Convention, would argue as the state debated its place in the Union. Only 58 years earlier the territory had been purchased from the French at 3 cents per acre, but the US ban on the African slave trade and importation had created prosperity and it flourished. By 1840, only 28 years since it had been admitted as a full state, its premier city, New Orleans had grown to one of the largest and wealthiest in the country. Even as the population of the Bayou state grew to almost three quarters of a million, they knew that everything relied on the 47 to 48 percent of the population that lived in the bonds of that brutal and bitter subjugation known by that simple word: Slavery. They could not and would not abide under a President that would rip from them what they considered their property, and, in turn, destroy their prosperity. To many of them he wasn’t even their President. How could he be when he wasn’t even on the ballot in the state? He would not then be allowed to destroy their way of life. Action needed to be taken.
On January 26th, 1861 it was by a vote of 113 to 17 as the Secessionist Convention made its intentions clear. The cannons would fire and the masses would gather an cheer as fireworks were set off and a sense of jubilation filled the people of the state, as if a burden was lifted from them. Louisiana would become the 6th State to leave the Union, joining with South Carolina, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia in open defiance, declaring:
We, the people of the State of Louisiana, in convention assembled, do declare and ordain, and it is hereby declared and ordained, That the ordinance passed by us in convention on the 22d day of November, in the year eighteen hundred and eleven, whereby the Constitution of the United States of America and the amendments of the said Constitution were adopted, and all laws and ordinances by which the State of Louisiana became a member of the Federal Union, be, and the same are hereby, repealed and abrogated; and that the union now subsisting between Louisiana and other States under the name of "The United States of America" is hereby dissolved.
The truth was that Thomas Overton Moore perhaps had little intention of abiding by the results of the election if his side lost. Even as he was sworn in as the State’s 16th Governor in January of 1860, he declared, “At the North, a widespread sympathy with felons has deepened the distrust in the permanent Federal Government, and awakened sentiments favorable to a separation of states.” His view was that, “So bitter is this hostility felt toward slavery, which these fifteen states regard as a great social and political blessing, that it exhibits itself in legislation for the avowed purpose of destroying the rights of slaveholders guaranteed by the Constitution and protected by the Acts of Congress. Popular addresses, Legislative resolutions, Executive communications, the press and the pulpit, all inculcate hatred against us and war upon the institution of slavery – an institution interwoven with the very element of our existence.” When James Buchannan’s Vice President, John C. Breckinridge lost the general election, Moore would order the State Militia up. It would escalate the situation even before the convention met as he issued orders for them to seize all US Military posts within the state in the hopes of chasing the Federal Authority from their soil.
Yet it would be short lived. Union blockades would block commerce and trade in what was the third largest port in the United States, and the almost 700,000 tons of import that would travel through New Orleans would trickle to a halt, even as the drums of war would replace the sounds of jubilation. By 1862 the government would abandon Baton Rouge even as the Union Army under General Benjamin Butler pushed forward to occupy New Orleans. The child of the Mississippi, the state would find that it had no friend in it as the Union Army pushed up it to take the state, battle by battle. By 1865, as the Confederacy collapsed, whatever prosperity once flowed through the state had long since evaporated as it was brought back into the Union, the resistance of many of its people long since broken.
Watching the protesters take to the street it is hard to ignore the defiant shouts of "Not My President" or the signs that claim "Illegitimate President." Since November there have been any number of people who have been horrified by the election results, and have found themselves trying to figure out a way to keep him from moving forward with his agenda. Having tried to move the Electoral College to support another candidate and failing the focus of some have turned to other methods. Among these methods, is the call to Impeach Trump.
Even before he was sworn in, and less than a day after, people advocated using Article II, Section Four of the Constitution to remove President Trump from office. Yet no cause can be shown as to why except that they do not like him. They do not like his agenda, and they do not agree with his platform, he has made appointments to Cabinet they don't like and spoke and acted in ways they don't like. At it's heart is a call to essentially politicize the impeachment process and make it into nothing more than a partisan weapon that can be wielded whenever one does not like an election result.
In this full length episode Wyatt talks about the dangers of pushing for impeachment before it is time and before it is right, the dangers of rushing the process. He goes through what the Founders intended and what impeachment really means as a part of the path to removing a President from Office. Join him for another journey into politics and the Constitution.
The lines were being drawn. Abraham Lincoln had been elected the 16th President of the United States. Whatever concessions, whatever favor the South might have found under the Administration of James Buchanan, they knew it was quickly drawing to a close as the March Inauguration of the Republican from Illinois fast approached. South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida and Alabama had already seceded from the Union. They would not suffer a man who would deprive them of their slaves. To them slavery was more than an economic institution, though their prosperity could not long stand without it, it was a moral one as well. Yet these four states that had since left were not the only states that relied on brutal subjugation for financial security and stability and soon, they knew other states would join their cause.
On January 19th, 1861 Georgia would be the fifth state to hear that call, declaring, “that the union now existing between the State of Georgia and other States under the name of the United States of America is hereby dissolved, and that the State of Georgia is in full possession and exercise of all those rights of sovereignty which belong and appertain to a free and independent State.” They knew who the enemy was, Abraham Lincoln, and the Republican Party. “We know their treachery; we know the shallow pretenses under which they daily disregard its plainest obligations. If we submit to them it will be our fault and not theirs…” they would declare in their Declaration of Cause.
The truth was that it was no surprise. The 39 year old Governor Joseph Brown, who would serve as the state’s chief magistrate during the entirety of the Civil War, would see the writing on the wall almost as soon as the 1860 Election drew to a close. “Submission to the administration of Mr. Lincoln will result in the final abolition of slavery. If we fail to resist now, we will never again have the strength to resist…” he would reflect in an open letter. Had it been up to him and him alone Georgia would have likely left the Union first as he became a leading advocate for secession. Yet, even as he and others pushed for open defiance and separation from the Union, they believed it was not only their right but that they would be able to do so peaceably, with little resistance, writing, “The President in his late message, while he denies our Constitutional right to secede, admits that the General Government has no Constitutional right to coerce us back into the Union, if we do secede. Secession is not likely, therefore, to involve us in war. Submission may. When the other States around us secede, if we remain in the Union, thousands of our people will leave the State, and it is feared that the standard of revolution and rebellion may be raised among us, which would at once involve us in civil war among ourselves. If we must fight, in the name of all that is sacred, let us fight our common enemy, and not fight each other.” Yet even as fourth State admitted into the Union prepared to become the fifth to leave it, the hopes of a peaceful separation were quickly evaporating as tensions quickly escalated and shots were being fired before war was even declared.
Not all of Georgia was convinced though. Much of the Northern portion of the State, which bordered North Carolina, and the ever-divided Tennessee, found themselves opposed to leaving the Union. 5,000 from the State would leave their homes to fight for the Union, knowing perhaps that if the war was lost, they would not have a home to return to. Rabun County in the North East portion of the state, refused to declare loyalty to the Confederacy, operating as if they had never left the Union. In Fannin County Confederate guerillas would line up and execute Georgians they caught trying to enlist in the Union Army. It was not the only tragedy pro-Union factions in Georgia would face as they were brutally cut down, slaughtered for their loyalty to the Government and the Constitution that their state had helped to form only a few generations prior.
In the end one had to wonder if Georgia and Governor Brown began to feel as they traded one master for another. Even as they found themselves in the ranks of the Confederacy, the dream was, in his mind, greater than the reality. He would find himself often in open conflict with the new Federal Government and President Jefferson Davis. Even as he brought his state in the looser confederation he couldn’t help but feel as if his state’s rights were being violated by conscription, impressment of goods and by the taking of Georgia soldiers out of the state. It wouldn’t matter anyways. The state that was largely left to be until 1863 wood soon come into the sights of Major General William Tecumseh Sherman. His Atlanta Campaign and March to the Sea was about to unleash hell on the state in a scorched earth campaign that would bring the state to its knees.