Fragile Freedom

Fragile Freedom

By Wyatt McIntyre, Matthew J. Cochran
Download on the App Store

All Fragile Freedom episodes

  • January 17th, 1781

    It had only been four years since Brigadier-General Daniel Morgan had been returned in an exchange, having been taken prisoner by the British following defeat at the Battle of Quebec. Ever defiant, the man who once took a bullet to the back of the neck, knocking out teeth, and had received 499 lashes from a British whip for knocking out a British Lieutenant who struck him with the flat end of his sword, bragging they still owed him one more, he had surrendered his sword to a French-Canadian Priest rather than offer it to the Colony’s Governor, General Guy Carleton. Even as his 500 handpicked riflemen had help secure victory at the Battle of Saratoga, it was clear to General Washington that the trade had paid off. Now, he and his troops had been sent South to assist General Nathanael Greene in his under gunned and under manned efforts in South Carolina. Greene’s plans were simple, he would use the highly-trained riflemen in guerilla warfare, knowing that though they were outnumbered they could plunge a knife in the heart of the British with the right tactics. In response, Lord Cornwallis would unleash the fury of the Green Dragoon, Bloody Ban Tarleton, in an attempt to counter.

    It would be in that effort that on January 17th, 1781 Colonel Tarleton would form his line, having chased Morgan through the hills and fields of South Carolina, to strike at Cowpens. Yet Morgan not only counted on that, he had hoped for it, knowing the British officer’s tendency to strike first and strike hard. Knowing how notoriously unreliable the militia was, how it would abandon a battle at the first sign of hardship, he set his troops in two separate position that made fleeing the battle impossible if the army was routed. This would not be another Battle of Camden, and though his regulars were better trained, with better, more accurate weaponry than muskets, they would be soon cut down without support. Even as Tarleton hit there would be no place to go if they let him push too hard and too far, it would be fight and win, or die. They were to fire twice, and flee quickly behind the regulars who were harder and more determined in battle. Yet, the truth was that these were not ordinary Militia. Many of them were battle hardened at Kings Mountain. They had faced the British Bayonets and had survived to take the day. In the hills sharpshooters would be positioned under the command of Major John Cunningham of Georgia and Colonel Joseph McDowell of North Carolina. The British hadn’t counted on it and even as they pushed forward, moving into first strike position they would play right into Morgan’s hands.

    As the British advanced Morgan would repeat the famous line, "Don't fire until you see the whites of their eyes!" The soldiers would cheer as the British charged, and charged again amidst the rising fog of musket fire and the clashing thunder of the hooves shook the ground. “They give us the British Hallo, boys. Give them the Indian Hallo, by God!” Morgan would cry out to his troops. They would push back even as the British ordered the second charge. This would force the Continental Army back from their position, and play into the arrogance of Colonel Tarleton. For him the battle was won, he just needed to take to the field and pluck it from the smoke and the ashes. He would order a general charge. It would be a mistake. As the British moved forward with their full force, Colonel William Washington would lead his Calvary down from the right as the militia pushed forward from the left as they quickly overwhelmed the Bloody Ban’s forces.

    It wouldn’t be bad enough for the British that Morgan had roundly defeated them, but by capturing the majority of the British Forces, 700 to 900 troops in all, he took from Lord Cornwallis some of his best and bravest, some of England’s best trained, and most experienced troops now marched off as prisoners of war. Even as Colonel Washington charged Tarleton would barely escape capture as his horse was shot out from under him when one of the surgeons from 71st Highlanders would give him his own.  Morgan would leave the Wizard Owl, Colonel Andrew Pickens to tend to the wounded, bury the dead and care for the prisoners under a white flag as he quickly fled with his troops to North Carolina, knowing Cornwallis would soon be coming for him and the troops he claimed.

    It wouldn’t matter. South Carolina had reached the edge and Cowpens had pushed it over. The end was coming for the British as General Greene prepared now to take back the state. It was only now a matter of time.

    It would be the beginning of the end of the British engagement in South Carolina.

     

    9 min
  • January 11th, 1861

    Until this point, the states that seceded from the Union had been perhaps more diplomatic when it came to their Ordinances of Secession, passing sweeping statements rather than commentaries on the current political climate or tensions that had arose with the election of 1860. Though the undertones were there, the closest mention even to slavery was the term “Property” used two days prior when Mississippi declared its own intention to withdraw from the United States.

    Then, on January 11th, 1861 Alabama became the fourth State to declare itself free of the Constitution and the authority of the Federal Government in Washington D.C.. The language was plain, and without any pretexts, as it declared:

    Whereas, the election of Abraham Lincoln and Hannibal Hamlin to the offices of president and vice-president of the United States of America, by a sectional party, avowedly hostile to the domestic institutions and to the peace and security of the people of the State of Alabama, preceded by many and dangerous infractions of the constitution of the United States by many of the States and people of the Northern section, is a political wrong of so insulting and menacing a character as to justify the people of the State of Alabama in the adoption of prompt and decided measures for their future peace and security…

    In their mind Abraham Lincoln would never be their President, nor would they recognize the authority of a regional Northern Government under Lincoln and Maine Senator turned Vice President-Elect Hannibal Hamlin. They would not respect that authority, nor would they abide by the peaceful transition of power that had been a hallmark of the American republican democracy since the nations inception. No, this election challenged the institution on which the economy of the State of Alabama was built on. Of the over 964,000 people who resided in the state, just over 435,000 were slaves. It drove the prosperity of the state, and to the slaveholding population of the state, it was not just an economic institution, but as the newspapers in the state would also declare, a religious one as well.

    The truth was there was little question that Alabama would leave the Union. In February of the year prior the State Legislature had passed legislation requiring the state to elect delegates to a secessionist convention if a “Black Republican” were to win the Presidency. In December those elections were called by Governor Andrew Moore, and the convention was set for January 7th. Moore though had already begun to make moves before the Secessionist Convention even met. Anticipating the state’s desire to leave, he would order troops to seize Fort Gaines and Fort Morgan on Mobile Bay as well as the Arsenal at Mount Vernon as early as the 3rd and the 4th of January. Under his orders 500 Alabama Troops marched to Florida to assist Governor Madison Perry take the Fort at Pensacola, even as the fellow slaveholding state prepared to leave the Union. Not only did they declare that they wished to meet with other slave states to form a new confederacy, but they also acted on it, taking hardline steps to not only chase the Union from their state, to decrease their financial reliance on the North and ensure their own stability during this unstable time, but also to assist their neighbors in this cause.

    Even as the fourth of the original six founding states of the Confederate States of America severed its bonds in open defiance to the United States, it wouldn’t be long before the new rebel nation would be formed. Though Richmond would eventually become the Capital, in those early days Montgomery would serve as the first capital of the CSA. Moore would be an influential player, tirelessly working to ensure the election of Jefferson Davis as the first President. Though some would argue for cooler heads to prevail, and for compromise to be struck, it was too late, and Alabama, swayed too heavily by the cause of slavery would not hear it. Still, at least some would remain loyal to the Union, with the 1st Alabama Calvary choosing to place first the United States, over its loyalty to that of its state. It would be at least one sign of the depth of the divide in the nation that would pit brother against brother and neighbor against neighbor as the blood of its people stained the soil, and the soul, of the nation.

    9 min
  • January 10th, 1861

    One of the original Thirteen Colonies, South Carolina had signed the Declaration of Independence and was the 8th State to ratify the Constitution on May 23rd, 1788. Mississippi had been a state for now over 40 years. It was reaching the point where only the older generation remembered when it was an open territory against the vast western frontier. Though not as young as Oregon or Minnesota or California, Florida, on the other hand, had only been a state for 15 years, only just over half a year older than Texas. It was entirely possible that there had been many in the state who remembered what it was like before the Florida Purchase Treaty ceded the Spanish territory to the US in 1822, combining East and West Florida into the Florida Territory.

    Yet on January 10th, 1861, Florida would become the third state to secede from the Union. Once declared a “Free and Independent State” in its Constitution, it was now ready to declare itself an “Sovereign and Independent Nation” in an open convention that agreed by a vote of sixty-two to seven to leave the “the Confederacy of States existing under the name of the United States of America”.

    Even before Florida seceded, Governor Madison Perry foresaw the possibility of withdrawal as a potential option, and even perhaps an inevitable necessity. A small state in terms of population, the economy was reliant on slavery as a cheap source of labor to ensure its prosperity. Though the issue of slavery, or, as the Mississippi Ordinance of Secession passed the day prior referred to it, property never arose in the third state’s own declaration, it had to be a prevalent thought in the minds of all voting Floridians. Of the just over 140,000 people who lived in the state, almost 62,000 of them were slaves.  If the system were to be challenged, or changed then the economy would collapse. Three wars with the Seminoles Indians had already been fought, at least in part, because they provided sanctuary and safety to runaway slaves. Perry encouraged the state to reinstate the militia even as it was being dissolved in 1858. Yet, prone to drunkenness, claiming to be on patrol when they were at home working their fields, the militia had lost the trust of the people. Still, Perry was right, and following the vote for secession, he demanded the complete evacuation of all Federal Government Troops from Florida soil.

    When the Confederacy would be formed Florida would be one of the Original 6 founding states. Texas would be admitted before fighting would break out in the South, while the remaining 4 states would join after. Far to the South, it would not see much fighting nor many battles before the end of the War, and Tallahassee would be the only Southern Capital that had not been captured by the Union Army before the end of the War. Yet, even as the dreams of the Confederacy died, Governor John Milton, the successor to Governor Perry, would declare he would rather die than live under the flag of the Union and what he would call the odious character of the Yankee. With the end of the war just over a month away, and the weight of everything bearing down on him he would shoot himself in the head.

    Regardless, the nation was lining up and the lines were being drawn as the nation prepared to answer, with force, the question they struggled and failed to answer with their pens over the course of the past 84 years. War was coming and it would be the bloodiest ever faced by America as brother quickly turned against brother in the great conflict.

    8 min
  • January 9th, 1861

    Only a few weeks prior, on December 20th, 1860, South Carolina seceded from the Union, becoming the first state to leave. Even before then tension had been building with the election of Abraham Lincoln as president. With roughly 40% of the popular vote but almost 60% of the Electoral College, there was little doubt that he would be sworn in as the 16th President of the United States. It was a prospect that many in the South refused to live with. To them the Constitution created a voluntary union rather than a binding one, and they had the right to peaceably leave at any point.

    On January 9th, 1861, almost two months before the Inauguration of the President-Elect, Mississippi, the 20th state to be admitted into the Union, became the second state to exercise what they believed to be their right. Congressman Lucius Lamar would draft, “An ordinance to dissolve the union between the State of Mississippi and other States united with her under the compact entitled "The Constitution of the United States of America’”, outlining not only its desire to secede, but to form a new confederacy with other states that would chose also to separate. In their declaration and justification of secession, they would argue, “Utter subjugation awaits us in the Union, if we should consent longer to remain in it. It is not a matter of choice, but of necessity. We must either submit to degradation, and to the loss of property worth four billions of money, or we must secede from the Union framed by our fathers, to secure this as well as every other species of property. For far less cause than this, our fathers separated from the Crown of England. Our decision is made. We follow their footsteps. We embrace the alternative of separation; and for the reasons here stated, we resolve to maintain our rights with the full consciousness of the justice of our course, and the undoubting belief of our ability to maintain it.” Slavery would be maintained. Joining with South Carolina, they would remain firm in their assertion that these African-Americans were their property, and that the economic value of slavery outweighed the benefit of the 84-year-old nation, forged together under the Constitution just over 70 years prior.

    Yet the hopes of a peaceful separation was perhaps quickly fading. What Mississippi Governor John Pettus, who campaigned on secession and the formation of a southern confederacy to preserve slavery, and other secessionists in his state didn’t know was that to the East, on that same day, the civilian steamship the Star of the West sailed for Charleston Harbor. It was loaded with supplies for the garrison stationed at Fort Sumter under the command of Major Robert Anderson, the man who in a few short months would, to the Union, become the hero of that first battle of the Civil War and promoted to Brigadier-General. It wouldn’t reach its destination nor fulfill that contract for the US Government. Major Peter Stevens, Superintendent of the Citadel, had received orders from South Carolina’s Governor Francis Pekins, to take cadets and man the strategic battery on Morris Island. If they were to see a vessel flying an American flag they were to fire. Three shots would hit the Spirit of the West, forcing the ships Captain, John McGowan, to turn and sail back to New York. Though open hostilities would not begin until April, the first shots of the Civil War had been fired as South Carolina openly defied the authority and the jurisdiction of the Union Government. Three days later Pekins would demand that the US Government surrender Fort Sumter and remove its troops from South Carolina soil, now, in the minds of the residents of that state, free of the ties that bound it to the United States. Of course it would remain in US possession until the first battle of the Civil War would be fought, almost exactly three months after his demands were made.

    Mississippi, South Carolina, and the states of the Confederacy would eventually, after the long and bloodied war between the states, be brought back into the Union. Pickens, once so proud and defiant, would make the motion to repeal the South Carolina Ordinance of Secession. Lucius Lamar would receive a Presidential Pardon, and serve as the first Democrat elected to the House of Representatives after the Civil War, before election to the Senate, and appointment to Cabinet as Secretary of the Interior and, finally, the Supreme Court. The Star of the West, on the other hand, would meet an untimely fate. After being commissioned in by the Department of War, it would end up trading hands between the Union and the Confederacy, before being sunk in 1863. In the end it became just another bill for the United States to pay for its history of ignoring the issue of slavery, though, in this case, one that it could pay with a simple check to the US Mail Steamship Company. Other prices would be less monetary but much higher, taking longer to pay.

    10 min
  • January 5th, 1781

    By September of 1780 the plans of the brilliant commander Major-General Benedict Arnold to surrender West Point, New York to the British had been exposed. Heavily indebted, having spent the majority of his fortune on the War Effort, injured in battle, with his shattered leg set so crudely it was then two inches shorter than the other, forcing him to walk with a cane, and watching as others took credit for his victories and successes, investigated by the Continental Congress for corruption, court-marshalled, and passed up for promotion, he had lost faith in the colonial cause of independence. Fleeing to the British, he would receive a commission as a Brigadier-General and orders from General Sir Henry Clinton, Commander-in-Chief of North America: bring Virginia back into the Imperial Fold.

    The January 5th, 1781 Raid on Richmond was not necessarily a surprise. Even as Arnold sailed his 1,600 Green Coats up the James River, destroying plantations, and laying waste to the towns along the route to Westover, he had his eye on the state capital 25 miles away. It was only a matter of time before he arrived at the heart of the defiant southern colony that was home not only to the author of the Declaration of Independence, but also the Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army, and take its premier city. Yet Governor Thomas Jefferson, he couldn’t raise the men necessary to defend the city, most of whom had believed that they had done their service to the cause of independence already. Only 200 militia men would take up arms to defend their homes against the force of a regular army comprised of infantry, dragoon and artillery that outnumbered them 8 to 1. Outgunned and outflanked, they didn't stand a chance, especially against the more experienced British Commanders such as Lieutenant Colonel John Dundas of the Edinburg Regiment and Lieutenant Colonel John Graves Simcoe of the Queen’s Rangers. Even as Arnold quickly approached Richmond the only answer Jefferson could manage was to move the capital to Williamsburg, a stronger strategic location to defend, and the cities supplies to a foundry just outside of Richmond. Still, he remained, at least initially, for the defense of the city. But as the small militia, under the command of Colonel John Nicholas, stationed on Richmond Hill near the St. John’s Church, that place where Patrick Henry only a few years prior gave his famous ‘Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death ‘ address, broke after barely a volley of musket fire, Simcoe pursued, and the American Calvary, watching from a not so distant position fled. Jefferson knew the city was lost. He would order the immediate evacuation, ensuring the removal of any military supplies as well as the families of government officials before fleeing the city himself. By noon Arnold marched the streets of Richmond the conquering hero of the campaign but it wouldn’t be enough. Finding the supplies had been moved by Jefferson, he would dispatch a messenger to the Governor. The request would be simple, load the cities supplies on the British Ships and the city would remained unscathed. Perhaps, had it been anyone else commanding the British Forces, Jefferson might have been more open to the request, but to turn the cities stores over to the treacherous Arnold, the man who plotted the surrender of West Point, the man who betrayed the cause of Independence and turned his back on liberty, was a disgusting prospect that wouldn’t be even considered. When his response reached Arnold the next day, the Brigadier General was livid. He would ransack the city, burning houses, destroying government papers, and laying waste to buildings. Word would soon spread of the ransacking of Richmond, and Jefferson would ask for the help of Colonel Sampson Matthews and the Virginia Militia to put Arnold on the defensive even as General Washington dispatched the Marquis de Lafayette to route the British and capture the traitor turned British Commander and summarily execute him. Matthews would put Arnold on the defensive even as Lafayette would arrive with reinforcements in time to prevent the second raid on Richmond.

    Though Arnold would escape and be hailed as a hero by the British for what would be his most successful campaign for their cause, the long-term effects hoped for by the English was not felt. They had hoped that Arnold’s exploits would rally Loyalists to rise up and force Virginia and then the South back into the fold. It did not. Though it increased the British ranks with former slaves who now enlisted in exchange for their freedom, the land campaign of the Revolutionary War would be over before the year ended with the Siege of Yorktown, Virginia, and America would secure its sovereignty as a free and independent nation, with Arnold sent into exile, settling first in the British Colony of Saint John, New Brunswick in present day Canada and then London. He would die penniless, and would be buried in his Continental Army Uniform at St. Mary's in Middlesex in the city of London.

    10 min
  • January 3rd, 1777

    As Lord Charles Cornwallis confidently marched his 9,000 troops towards Trenton he believed that he had him. He would overwhelm the exhausted Continental Army 5,000 troops strong, and push them back. Even as he ordered his soldiers back for the evening he would arrogantly proclaim, “We've got the old fox safe now. We'll go over and bag him in the morning.” He would capture General Washington and deliver a deathblow to the colonial rebellion that had dared to proclaim its independence from the Empire not even half a year prior.  Yes, he knew that the crafty American General would be too wise to face a force of regulars that outnumbered his forces almost 2 to 1, especially worn and weary from battle, and would more than likely seek to flee. Yet General Cornwallis would not be denied his victory or that swift end to hostilities. He would send soldiers to guard the Delaware, believing that Washington would once more cross where he had initially launched his winter campaign on the evening of the 25th/morning of the 26th.

    Yet the 44-year-old Virginian would not be so easily caught, and he had grander designs. Leaving the tents up and the campfires burning he muffled the sound of the wheels of the wagons, and took his troops North to Princeton where the odds were more in his favor.

    Running behind schedule on January 3rd, 1777, Washington had planned to attack the garrison under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Charles Mawhood before dawn. Yet the city remained in the distance even as the sun broke. It wouldn’t be long before Lord Cornwallis charged on his camp to find it empty. Once he had, and not having received word that the Colonials marched in retreat at the Delaware he might begin to put two and two together. To prevent, or at least hinder Cornwallis from following, Washington would order Brigadier-General Hugh Mercer to take 350 men to destroy the bridge over the Stoney Brook stream. Had Washington remained on schedule they would have met little to no resistance as Cornwallis had ordered Mawhood’s troops to Trenton to meet him. But they would spot the American Forces. Knowing time was limited and that the British would charge on their position, Washington would order Mercer to confront the force before it had the chance to attack the main army. It would be on that field that the man who fled to America a fugitive from his home in Scotland after having served in the army of Bonnie Prince Charlie, the veteran of the Battle of Culloden, would fall, stabbed repetitively by bayonets by the British soldiers who surrounded him for refusing to surrender. Nine days later, despite the care received by Dr. Benjamin Rush, he would die.

    Still, it would not be enough, nor would the inexperience of the roughly 1,000 Pennsylvania troops under General John Cadwalader. “Parade with us my brave fellows! There is but a handful of the enemy and we shall have them directly!" Washington would cry out as a small band of fresh troops from Rhode Island arrived under the command of Colonel Daniel Hitchcock. It would be the last battle of the brave commander of the 2nd Rhode Island Regiment who had led his troops since the Siege of Boston in 1775.  Within ten days he would be dead of tuberculous. Mawhood would still try. Moving out of the range of the American artillery they would attempt to break the American line. Lieutenant Colonel John Fitzgerald, the Irish Catholic who served as Washington’s Secretary, would cover his eyes with his hat, sure that as the smoke of battle overtook them, that General Washington had fallen. He could not bear to see it if he had. Yet as it settled, there Washington sat atop his horse, unscathed, unflinching in the face of fire or the threat of death.

    The Continental Army would force the British from the field. Some would flee, others would retreat, while others yet would take refuge in Nassau Hall, what is now considered the oldest building at Princeton University, at that point though only 20 years old and the largest academic building in the Colonies. The Americans would push. Alexander Hamilton would set up the artillery and fire on the hall as the troops charged, forcing the British surrender. Washington would order the pursuit of fleeing soldiers. There wouldn’t even be enough time to save the Artillery as the Militia pursued. Even the Dragoons ordered to buy the British time to flee were pushed back. Despite claims by Loyalist Papers that greatly exaggerated the Revolutionary losses, Washington would report 31 to 37 dead on the field, while British Commander William Howe would report almost 20 dead, 58 wounded and 200 captured, though the numbers were more than likely higher, with some putting the British deaths at 375.

    General Henry Knox, a man so trusted by Washington he would serve as the first Secretary of War, and General Nathaniel Greene, who began the Revolution enlisted as a private and quickly rose through the ranks, a gifted strategist, would talk the Commander-in-Chief from attacking New Brunswick, New Jersey. Yet it would mark the end of the New Jersey Winter Campaign that began with the crossing of the Delaware. Howe would abandon the state, the Hessian mercenaries would be forced out, and the Loyalists would be sent into exile.

    10 min
  • December 29th, 1845

    When the Texas War of Independence ended on April 21st, 1836 there were many in the newly formed Southern Republic that believed it would be openly welcomed into the United States as a part of the Union. Yet, there was more to consider than just territorial expansion. President Andrew Jackson had remained neutral on the issue during the Revolution that begun in his final year in office, believing that Texas wouldn’t be able to stand alone or maintain its independence against the newly formed Centralist Republic of Mexico. As the slavery question raged on he didn’t want to give an issue to the anti-slavery candidates by recognizing the large slaveholding nation that, in his opinion, was doomed to failure. Martin Van Buren, his successor, would recognize Texas as free and independent in 1837 but he was unwilling to welcome a new state that would ultimately shift the equilibrium struck with the 1820 Missouri Compromise, which established the balance of free versus slave states in the Union. At any rate Mexico refused to recognize the legitimacy of the newly seceded nation. To welcome it into the United States would be to welcome hostilities with that southern neighbor, hostilities that could very easily escalate into war. Still, less than a decade after Texas first won its independence, a series of events would occur that would see the Lone Star Republic being welcomed as the 28th State in the Union on December 29th, 1845.

    When William Henry Harrison was elected President few people perhaps foresaw him dying within 32 days of his inauguration and Vice President John Tyler ascending to the highest office of the land. With 8 men having served before Harrison none had failed to serve the full tenure of the office. Yet as pneumonia made the now 68-year-old Harrison’s Presidency the shortest in history, Tyler had to take the reins. Soon it would begin to crumble. His opponents would refuse to recognize his legitimacy referring to him as the Acting President or as the Vice President, the majority of Cabinet would resign, finding him impossible to work with, he would be expelled from the Whig Party and forced to remain as an independent. The Senate would hold up or reject his cabinet appointments, which had, until that point, been practically unheard of, and by 1842 the House, outraged by his use of a veto on the Tariff Bills the Whigs favored, was seeking to bring articles of impeachment against him, something that had, until that point had been more constitutional theory than anything else. Though it ultimately was tabled, Tyler was dying a slow political death. Yet if there was a path to saving his Presidency Tyler believed it laid through Texas, it could even, in his mind, secure his re-election in 1844. Yet it would not be soon enough and the hopes he had of securing his own mandate faded even as treaties were signed. As he faced tough opposition in the House and Senate, and setbacks, he looked to another path. A Democrat before he joined the Whig Party that saw his election on the Harrison ticket, as he shifted towards the Democratic Party once more, they were not yet willing to welcome him back to the fold, and as James Polk was nominated by the Democrats, Tyler formed his own new Democratic-Republican Party, styled in the form of the late Thomas Jefferson under the slogan “Tyler and Texas”. Ultimately his goal wouldn’t be win, the chances of that had slipped through his grasp. It was to appear as a potential spoiler and to strike a deal with Polk to force him into an annexation position. Polk and Tyler would enter a secret pact at the encouragement of Andrew Jackson, a supporter of annexation, where Tyler encouraged his supporters to back the Democratic nominee having been assured that Polk would push annexation. In the end the Democrats would win the Presidency by a narrow margin, 49.5 to 48.1% in the popular vote, 170 to 101 seats in the Electoral College. Texas would be one of Polk’s first orders of business.

    Tyler’s legacy would not be safe, despite believing that Texas’ admittance in the Union would vindicate him. For him, the saving grace was that he would go from being considered one of the worst Presidents in history to the obscure. Still, he would perhaps be best remembered not for Texas but for being the only former President to side with the Confederacy during the Civil War, serving not only in the Virginia Secession Convention but the Confederate Congress before his death in 1862.

    9 min
  • December 28th, 1832

    There was little doubt that the John C. Calhoun who began his career as a Congressman representing the 6th District of South Carolina and who rose to serve as James Monroe’s Secretary of War, was a different man politically than the John C. Calhoun who was overwhelmingly selected to serve as the 7th Vice President of the United States under both John Quincy Adams and his successor Andrew Jackson. A supporter of protective tariffs, he would begin to oppose them and where he once advocated a strong Federal Government, his allegiances began to shift towards State’s Rights, and limited, more restrained authority. It would be this political realignment that would, on December 28th, 1832, lead him to become the first Vice President to resign the Office.

    The significance of Calhoun leaving the office was not in the fact that he had. Former Senator and Governor of New York turned Secretary of State Martin Van Buren would already be elected to replace Calhoun as Jackson’s Vice President. Increasingly at odds with President Jackson, Calhoun had assured Van Buren’s place as his successor in his attempt to destroy the man’s political career by casting the tie-breaking vote to block him from serving as US Minister to the United Kingdom. As the Nullification Debate raged on, Calhoun was the leader of that ideological movement that believed States had the right to nullify federal laws within their borders. As Senator Robert Y. Haynes had proven ill-equipped to defend South Carolina’s position, especially when faced Massachusetts Senator Daniel Webster in the Senate Debate, he would leave for the Governor’s Office while Calhoun would take over his seat in the Senate. Part of the issue here was that the Supreme Court, under then Chief Justice John Marshall, had already rejected Nullification as early as 1809 in the United States v. Peters, stating, “If the legislatures of the several States may, at will, annul the judgments of the courts of the United States, and destroy the rights acquired under those judgments, the Constitution itself becomes a solemn mockery, and the nation is deprived of the means of enforcing its laws by the instrumentality of its own tribunals. So fatal a result must be deprecated by all, and the people of Pennsylvania, not less than the citizens of every other State, must feel a deep interest in resisting principles so destructive of the union, and in averting consequences so fatal to themselves.” James Madison, one of the Chief Architects of the Constitution would assert that the Federal Courts, not the states, had the power to determine the Constitutionality of a federal law. Still, the Nullification Crisis was a long time coming in the new nation as States and the Federal Government both sought to assert their place and their power within the Republic. Yet despite most of the states challenging the Federal Authority at one point or another, Calhoun and South Carolina would stand alone in 1832 in their disregard of the Tariffs of 1828 and 1832, even though most of the Southern States still reliant on a slave economy had a stake in asserting the ability to invalidate Federal Law. The situation would escalate with South Carolina preparing to assert nullification by force if necessary and President Andrew Jackson ready to respond in kind.

    Eventually the issue would become moot as a compromise would be reached. Yet, as Andrew Jackson would recognize, the issue would be far from over, stating, “"the tariff was only a pretext, and disunion and southern confederacy the real object. The next pretext will be the negro, or slavery question." Still, until 1973, when Spiro Agnew stepped down, he was the only man to ever resign from the Vice Presidency. Though he would remain in the Senate and serve briefly as Secretary of State, the Presidency that he wanted would remain forever out of his grasp.

    8 min
  • December 27th, 1814

    When we hear The Battle of New Orleans General Andrew Jackson is perhaps the first person who comes to mind. His name would become immortalized in story and song defending the Southern city that had only become a part of the United States just over a decade prior with the Louisiana Purchase. Yet, in late 1814, it was Daniel Patterson who foresaw the British attack on New Orleans. In the middle of September he lead a force to the Southern Louisiana Base of the notorious Jean Lafitte at Barataria Bay, where, in routing the pirate, he laid claim to his ships, bringing the French-American Pirate to the aid of the American cause. General Jackson wanted Commodore Patterson to sail with his small makeshift fleet to Mobile Bay to engage the British. Patterson would refuse. To engage the vastly superior British navy there would allow for them to bottlenecked. His small fleet at that inlet to the Gulf of Mexico, making them an easy target. Instead he set about laying the defense of New Orleans. By December 12th sixty British ships under the command of Vice Admiral Sir Alexander Cochrane, Commander-in-Chief of the North American and Jamaica stations anchored 14,450 soldiers and sailors in the Gulf of Mexico. The British would begin their move on New Orleans.

    It would be Commodore Patterson’s defense that would delay the British. With a small, rag-tag band of ships that were no match for the power of the British fleet now in the Gulf he would push back, in the hopes that the reinforcements would soon arrive. It would save the city from being overrun by the British. Still, on December 27th, 1814 the USS Carolina, a schooner launched only 2 years prior from Charleston, South Carolina, would take heated shots from the British in an effort by the Royal Navy to destroy the resistance of the American force. The crew would be forced from her as she caught fire, and eventually exploded. It would be the last ship in Patterson’s little fleet that had caused the British so many difficulties in trying to lay claim to New Orleans. Yet if they thought that the destruction of the Carolina would have opened the door wide for an invasion of the city they would be sorely mistaken. Despite losing the last of his fleet that day Patterson had largely been effective in what he set out to do. He bought the time that the Americans needed for reinforcements to arrive. At the defense of the city, Patterson, a naval officer now with no ships any longer, would find his place offering artillery support to his compatriots, once more contributing to the decisive American victory that would push the British from Louisiana.

    Praised by Jackson, had it not been for Patterson, there would have been a distinct possibility that New Orleans would have fallen. What that would have meant is perhaps a mystery as the Treaty of Ghent had already been signed to end the War but was yet to be ratified by the US government. Regardless, for his efforts Patterson would go on to be promoted to Captain and would serve in the Mediterranean Squadron in command of the USS Constitution, the flagship of Commodore John Rodger’s Fleet. He would continue to serve in the Navy until his death in 1839 at 53.

    7 min
  • A Moment in our History

    A new short segment I am hoping to begin for Fragile Freedom called A Moment in our History.

    -----

    Having been for so many of those defining moments of the new nation, a constant guide, sacrificing tirelessly of himself as a member of the First and Second Continental Congress, Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army, delegate and president of the Constitutional Convention, the first President of these United States, there perhaps had to be a thought by many that even as George Washington retired, even as he once more removed himself public life he would always be there, ready to return when the struggling nation needed him, much like he had when the Articles of Confederation did not prove enough for the Republic. Yet within two years of leaving the Presidency he was gone.

    At dawn on December 26th, 1799 sixteen cannons would begin their bursts in Philadelphia, the national capital. They would volley every half an hour after as the Republic laid this giant of a man to rest. At noon soldiers began firing minute guns, they would continue for an hour. A mounted Trumpeter led the processional as two Marines wearing black scarves would escort an empty casket drawn by a horse with no rider. Two troops of horses would carry flags of mourning as they, with senior officers of the Infantry, Calvary and Artillery would follow. There had been a simpler funeral, one perhaps more reflective of Washington’s humbler nature, at his beloved Mount Vernon on the 18th of December. Here his body was laid to its final rest. But now the nation, that nation he gave so much of himself to, that nation that he had dedicated so much of his life in service to, needed to mourn the loss of its greatest hero, taken at 67 years of age.  The bells tolled and the guns fired as fifes, wind instruments and muffled drums haunted the “Solemn and August Pageantry” with George Fredrick Handel’s Dead March. Only the second national funeral the nation had held the Casket was taken from Legislative Hall to the German Church, Zion Lutheran, the largest place of worship in the city, where Episcopal Bishop William White, once the Chaplain of the Continental Congress, presided. So revered was General George Washington that, when word of his December 14th death reached the British the colors of the Royal Navy were lowered to half-mast. In France a ten day requiem was ordered by Napoleon to mourn the death of this great man. In a Eulogy Commissioned by Congress and delivered on that grim 26th, Henry Lee III, Light-Horse Harry Lee, former Governor of Virginia, and one time member of the Continental Congress, who served closely under Washington during the War and was present at the surrender of Lord Cornwallis, a man counted as a dear, personal friend and protégé of General Washington, would reflect, “To the memory of the Man, first in war, first in peace, and first in the hearts of his countrymen, he was second to none in the humble and endearing scenes of private life. Pious, just, humane, temperate and sincere—uniform, dignified and commanding—his example was as edifying to all around him as were the effects of that example lasting.”

    7 min