"Send us a Text!"

This week on the show we’re diving into two very different 90s classics: a film that restored our Christmas cheer and one that… frankly, left us scratching our heads.

First up is The Santa Clause — a heartwarming holiday adventure starring Tim Allen as Scott Calvin, a regular guy who literally becomes Santa Claus after an unexpected rooftop encounter with the real Saint Nick. As Scott navigates the hilarious and magical challenges of his new role — from growing a beard overnight to managing elves at the North Pole — the movie wins you over with its charm, family dynamics, and joyful take on belief and holiday spirit. We had a blast watching this one and it’s easily our favorite of the two. 

Then we turned to Sleepless in Seattle, the iconic Nora Ephron romantic comedy about a widower whose story on a national radio show sends countless admirers swooning — including a reporter (Meg Ryan) who becomes fixated on him from afar. While the film is beloved by many and often praised for its nostalgic tone and chemistry between Tom Hanks and Ryan, this time around it just didn’t land for us. The fate-as-romance premise felt contrived, pacing dragged, and we didn’t connect with the leads the way the movie seems to expect its audience to. 

If you’re choosing between these for your next movie night, stick with The Santa Clause for guaranteed feel-good family fun — and maybe save Sleepless in Seattle for when you’re in the mood for classic rom-com nostalgia, even if it’s not our favorite. Enjoy the discussion! 🎬✨

Follow us:

Facebook - Couch Critic Podcast

Instagram - @thecouchcriticpod