81 All Out - A Cricket Podcast

Greatness across eras: measures, challenges, and fallacies

Listen Later

In the latest episode of the podcast, we discuss the idea of greatness in cricket. What do we mean when we say a player is 'great', how does one compare across eras, and what are the pitfalls we fall into when discussing greatness.

Talking Points:

  • Greatness as a measurement of a player's performance against their peers
  • The habit of putting down one player as one elevates another
  • The need for a transcendent moment for a player to be anointed 'great'
  • The fallacy of the match-winning innings
  • Lillee v Cummins: the complexity of comparing two great bowlers
  • The power of nostalgia in talking about greatness - the Andy Roberts problem
  • Great batsmen in weak teams and great bowlers in strong teams
  • The problem with recency bias when judging greatness
  • Is this South African team better than the teams from the 1990s and 2000s?
  • The high benchmark for subcontinental players in foreign conditions

    • Support 81allout on Ko-fi

    Participants:

    Siddhartha Vaidyanathan (@sidvee)

    Mahesh Sethuraman (@cornerd)

    Kartikeya Date (@cricketingview)

    *

    Buy Cricket Beyond the Bazaar (recently republished by 81allout)

    India (hardback) | India (paperback, e-copy); Australia (hardback, paperback, e-copy); USA (hardback, paperback, e-copy); UK (hardback, paperback, e-copy); Canada (hardback, paperback, e-copy)

    Related:

    • The line of greatness - Siddhartha Vaidyanathan - The Cricket Monthly
    • Wisden 100 - Wikipedia
    • Who are the greatest T20 players of all - Kartikeya Date - ESPNcricinfo
    • Who are the best batsmen of each decade - Anantha Narayanan - ESPNcricinfo
    • The Richards standard for ODI batsmen - Kartikeya Date - ESPNcricinfo
    • A new measure for cricketing greatness - Andy Bull - Guardian
    • An all-time world Test XI, according to ICC rankings - Rupin Kale - Wisden
      • ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store
      81 All Out - A Cricket PodcastBy 81 All Out
      • 4.8
      • 4.8
      • 4.8
      • 4.8
      • 4.8

      4.8

      53 ratings

      More shows like 81 All Out - A Cricket Podcast

      View all
      Sky Sports Cricket Podcast by Sky Sports

      Sky Sports Cricket Podcast

      102 Listeners

      Stumped by BBC World Service

      Stumped

      40 Listeners

      Cyrus Says by IVM Podcasts

      Cyrus Says

      157 Listeners

      The Unplayable Podcast by cricket.com.au

      The Unplayable Podcast

      22 Listeners

      Following On by talkSPORT

      Following On

      35 Listeners

      The Final Word Cricket Podcast by Adam Collins, Geoff Lemon

      The Final Word Cricket Podcast

      96 Listeners

      Wisden Cricket Weekly by Wisden Cricket Weekly

      Wisden Cricket Weekly

      56 Listeners

      The Edges & Sledges Cricket Podcast by Edges & Sledges

      The Edges & Sledges Cricket Podcast

      51 Listeners

      The Cricket Podcast by The Cricket Podcast

      The Cricket Podcast

      53 Listeners

      In Focus by The Hindu by The Hindu

      In Focus by The Hindu

      37 Listeners

      Good Areas Podcast by Jarrod Kimber

      Good Areas Podcast

      53 Listeners

      Bits and Pieces : The friendliest cricket podcast by LLLC

      Bits and Pieces : The friendliest cricket podcast

      7 Listeners

      Batta Fast by Ahmer Naqvi and Osman Samiuddin

      Batta Fast

      8 Listeners

      Cricket Et Al by Cricket Et Al

      Cricket Et Al

      12 Listeners

      Two by Two by The Ken

      Two by Two

      4 Listeners