John Harbaugh’s reputation as the Giants’ culture-changing coach gets challenged by concerns over Baltimore’s recent penalty problems. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back, arguing that Harbaugh’s full track record matters more than two undisciplined seasons and that his toughness, consistency and playoff success are exactly what the Giants have been missing.

The conversation shifts to the Jets’ defensive uncertainty, Aaron Glenn’s decision to call plays and one caller’s outrageous theory that aliens may finally be on their side. The crew also examines Harbaugh’s slippery but likable media style, with Evan comparing his ability to defuse controversy to Buck Showalter.