Even if Y Combinator never existed, Matthew Sutton would still be backing the top builders. Most investors wait for traction. Matthew Sutton backs builders before there’s proof, sometimes before there’s even a category. He is the first check writer you want to have on your side.Operating at the intersection of Harvard Ventures and the YC ecosystems, Matthew has backed AI, quantum, and defense tech founders at the moment where conviction matters more than metrics.In this episode of Deeptech Decoded, we talk about what it really takes to back deep tech when spreadsheets are useless, categories don’t exist yet, and most ideas look wrong at the beginning. Most importantly, his investment thesis and founder-centric approach.He breaks down:◽️ How he evaluates AI, quantum, and defense founders without being technical yourself◽️ The CURSOR LESSON: why he passed on a $100M+ company and what founder evolution teaches.◽️ The 3 CRITERIA for backing pre-revenue deeptech:◽️ Why the best deep tech companies often look irrational early on◽️ The difference between hype, narrative, and real conviction◽️ AI bubble reality check: using communities and open source to validate vs. hype◽️ What Harvard and YC teach — and don’t teach — about failure Timestamps:00:00 – Introduction: Judgment before proof04:13 – From Wall Street to backing deeptech builders07:08 – First entrepreneurial ventures at age 12-1309:27 – Cambridge vs Silicon Valley: The per capita talent thesis11:37 – Why California wins at commercialization15:16 – Where real startups are built: Dorm rooms and iteration24:24 – Evaluating AI and quantum founders without being technical28:03 – SimpleBet: AI sports betting meets regulatory change31:37 – The Cursor miss: Passing on a $100M+ AI company and the lesson38:27 – Filtering deal flow: Spotting technical founders with conviction41:14 – Quantum investing before traction: The Segaldry story45:02 – Finding founders outside the Bay Area echo chamber51:21 – Defense tech's golden age: Golden Dome to rapid innovation55:59 – Moving fast in defense: Small bets in sensitive sectors58:25 – Leadership styles: Future creators vs past learners1:02:35 – AI bubble navigation: Discord communities as validation1:05:34 – Avoiding echo chambers: Stress testing investment thesis1:11:16 – Operational discipline without killing innovation1:16:10 – Founder suffering: Why resilience matters in deeptech1:25:18 – Teaching failure at Harvard: The straight-A paradox1:29:04 – What doesn't scare him about AI's future1:32:30 – Desert island question: Three startup essentials1:34:16 – Closing thoughtsFollow Matthew:...Follow us on:About Deeptech DecodedDeeptech Decoded is a podcast and newsletter for builders and backers working at the frontier of technology—from AI and quantum to defense, space, and infrastructure. We focus on product judgment, conviction, and what it really takes to build what doesn't exist yet.