Marshal Matt Dillon faces a moral dilemma when he decides to give young Steve Elser, a troubled drifter accused of cattle theft, a chance to redeem himself. With warnings from local ranchers and townsfolk echoing in his ears, Matt sets out to guide Elser toward a better path. However, the boy’s poor choices—befriending a known criminal, Ben Hander—test Matt’s resolve.

When Hander robs the Overland Express office and shoots the clerk, Matt discovers Elser with Hander, wearing a gun for the first time. Despite Elser’s protests of innocence, his involvement in Hander’s escape plan casts doubt on his intentions. In a gripping confrontation, Matt orders Elser to leave Dodge for good, only for the boy to draw his gun in a desperate attempt at revenge.

This heartbreaking tale explores themes of trust, redemption, and the painful realization that some people cannot be saved, no matter how much help they are given.

Keywords: "Gunsmoke Helping Hand episode," "September 1954 Gunsmoke radio," "Matt Dillon Steve Elser redemption," "Ben Hander robbery Gunsmoke," "Dodge City moral dilemmas," "John Meston Gunsmoke drama," "classic Western radio series."

Cast: William Conrad, Parley Baer, Howard McNear, Georgia Ellis, Sam Edwards, Lawrence Dobkin, Joe Cranston.