Dad Dimes

High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram: A Cozy Winter Rye Classic Review


Listen Later

🎙️ DadDimes on the Rocks – Season 4 Episode 25: “High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram: A Cozy Winter Rye Classic”


🏔️ Backstory & Concept

  • Producer: High West Distillery (Park City, UT)
  • Type: Rye whiskey blend, finished in ruby and tawny port barrels
  • Mash Bill: High-rye — mix of 95% rye / 5% barley (from MGP) + High West’s in-house 80% rye / 20% malted rye. 
  • Proof: 49.3% ABV (98.6 proof) for many acts. 
  • Release Style: Annual seasonal release — each batch is called an “Act.”


👃 Tasting Notes

Nose:
Deep and inviting — port barrels bring red berries, dark fruit, while the rye contributes spice, cedar, and baking notes

Palate:
A rich balance: you’ll taste berry jam (plum, cherry), fig, blackcurrant, with a peppery rye backbone. There’s also a syrupy sweetness from the port finish and a touch of ginger/orange peel

Finish:
Medium to long. Spices linger — ginger, allspice, some oak tannins, and a sweet wine-tinged fade. 



Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths:

  • Deeply seasonal feel — perfect for cold nights, holiday gatherings, or fireside sipping.
  • Great complexity from the port barrel finish — fruit-forward, winey, and rich.
  • High rye gives it character and bite, even with the sweetness of port.
  • Very collectible and loved: each “Act” has its own personality.

Caveats:

  • Limited release + high demand → can be hard to find and expensive.
  • Proof is moderate; not going to hit like barrel-proof rye.
  • Because the finish leans sweet, it might feel “heavy” for some with oak or sugar fatigue.
  • Batch-to-batch variation: flavor may shift depending on the “Act” and rye sources. 


🎯 DadDimes Verdict

Rating:4.3 / 5

Best For:

  • Rye lovers who appreciate bold finishing.
  • Holiday or winter sipping — when you want something festive, rich, and comforting.
  • Whiskey collectors or seasonal drinkers who enjoy annual “Acts” and limited releases.

Maybe Skip If:

  • You want a high-proof, punchy rye.
  • You dislike sweet, winey finish or fruit-forward whiskies.
  • You’re not into limited-batch or seasonal expressions.


🥂 Final Thoughts

Midwinter Night’s Dram is one of High West’s signature holiday whiskies — it feels like a warm, fruitcake-filled Christmas night in a glass. With each “Act,” it's like getting a new chapter in a story: familiar, but with subtle twists. If you can find an Act that fits your price range… grab it, let it sit for a bit in the glass, and enjoy the winter flavors.


That’s today’s pour on DadDimes on the Rocks. Until next time — stay warm, sip slow, and raise a glass to good whiskey and good company. Cheers! 🥃


...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Dad DimesBy Dad Dimes