We've been itching to do a horror themed episode for months! So we called horror icon Felissa Rose, and asked her to channel her inner Angela Baker to judge this bloody retro triple threat. Miscast Commentary's Joe Findlay is back with horror of 1984, and he's been bragging all week that he's going to slash the competition. Mancrush goes back to his senior year and brings the horror of 1996 to the table and Marc James summoned up the best horror of 1998 to make this a real bloodbath!