The Yankees finally broke out offensively, but the uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton has created a much bigger concern. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge can return as the same dominant player and what his absence means for the Yankees’ chances in the American League East.

They also examine how the Yankees should approach the trade deadline, why replacing Judge will require more than one move, and whether the current roster can produce enough offense to stay afloat. Plus, they react to Judge mocking Drew Rasmussen, Ryan McMahon’s game changing at bat, and the argument that money alone cannot guarantee success in baseball.