Part 6: Inbox Anxiety & the Mystery of Joe.MamaMary1927

In this episode, I reach peak “Catholic girl spiral” as I stare down an email that might—just might—be from Joseph Castillo. I imagine every possible scenario, from him being married with ten kids… to him asking for his handkerchief back (and offering me tissues instead). 🙃

With a little help from my sister, a late-night confession, and way too much overthinking, I finally open the email—and let’s just say, it wasn’t at all what I expected. Could this be the beginning of something… or just another twist in my not-yet-true love story?