The Listening Post

How virtual detectives exposed China's 're-education camps' | The Listening Post (Part Three)


Listen Later

Last year, alarming headlines began streaming into the global news cycle alleging that mass incarceration of Muslims was under way in China's Xinjiang province.
Reports of large numbers of Uighurs and other Turkic minorities disappearing into "re-education camps" had been circulating for a year or so prior, but difficulties in substantiating those allegations on the ground had kept the story well below the radar.
The source of long-running separatist sentiment and allegedly several incidents of violent "extremism", Xinjiang is a region under constant and extensive surveillance. Reporters are routinely harassed by the authorities, while Uighur sources have been known to simply disappear after talking to foreigners.
As a result, much of the evidence reporters have relied on has come from outside Xinjiang, and outside the journalistic field altogether - specifically, it has come from a small handful of independent researchers using methods defined as "open-source".
Used for investigating events such as drone attacks in Yemen and chemical weapons attacks in Syria, "open-source" is shorthand for the software and sources available to pretty much anyone with an internet connection. For those researching Xinjiang's camps, you can add the ability to read Mandarin.
Adrian Zenz, a German academic, is at the forefront of that effort. Speaking to The Listening Post's Daniel Turi near his home in the suburbs of Stuttgart, Zenz explains how, using the Chinese search-engine Baidu, he was able to unearth government documents that proved the existence of China's "internment programme", which officials in Beijing were denying.
"A key search term for this research was the Chinese word jiaoyu zhuanhua," says Zenz, "which literally means 'transformation through education'. When I put in the search term I found all kinds of government documents that very freely talked about transformation through education."
Chinese bureaucrats had left the evidence in plain sight, with government departments uploading official documents - including the policy's legal basis - onto the internet, seemingly without realising their incriminating nature.
The documents showed that China was indeed pursuing a policy of mass detention. But proving the camps were actually being built - enough of them to hold hundreds of thousands of people - required another "open-source" tool.
Shawn Zhang, a Chinese law student at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, was one of the first to realise the potential of satellite imagery to reveal the location and size of specific camps.
"I found lots of information, including government tender notices inviting companies to build the camps, and those included the addresses of almost a hundred of them. So I searched them on Google Earth and found the satellite images."
The next step, Zhang explains, was verification: "I needed to verify that these facilities were, in fact, re-education camps. On the satellite images, the re-education camp facilities look very different from civilian facilities. For example, their fences are much higher, and they contain structures used for detention, such as barbed wire and watchtowers. I was able to confirm that these facilities are indeed re-education camps, and so I published my findings on my blog."
The research by Zhang, Zenz and other "open-source" researchers has been integral to major news outlets reporting on Xinjiang, supplying journalists with the hard evidence - not to mention images - they needed to disprove the denials coming out of Beijing.
For Shawn Zhang, however, his status as a Chinese citizen means publishing his findings comes at a price.
"During my research, I have felt a lot of pressure from the Chinese government," Zhang said. "For example, they have contacted my family in China. So in the near future, I think I will avoid travelling to China because the Chinese government is not really happy about people telling truths that they don't want us to tell."
It is a price, however, that he insists is worth paying: "I think it is worth it because there are so many Uighur people held there. They just totally vanished, they disappear, like going into a black hole. They've lost contact with their families. At least my research can help international society to pressure the Chinese government so there can be a better chance of a peaceful solution."
Contributors:
Shawn Zhang - law student, University of British Columbia
Adrian Zenz - independent researcher
James Palmer - deputy editor, Foreign Policy
Yuan Yang - Beijing correspondent, Financial Times
- Subscribe to our channel: http://aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AJEnglish
- Find us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aljazeera
- Check our website: https://www.aljazeera.com/
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Listening PostBy Al Jazeera

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

37 ratings


More shows like The Listening Post

View all
The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,836 Listeners

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,754 Listeners

Focus on Africa by BBC World Service

Focus on Africa

372 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,072 Listeners

Talk to Al Jazeera by Al Jazeera

Talk to Al Jazeera

7 Listeners

The Interview by BBC World Service

The Interview

367 Listeners

The Electronic Intifada Podcast by The Electronic Intifada

The Electronic Intifada Podcast

307 Listeners

The Intercept Briefing by The Intercept

The Intercept Briefing

6,115 Listeners

Closer Than They Appear by Al Jazeera

Closer Than They Appear

619 Listeners

Game of Our Lives by Al Jazeera

Game of Our Lives

257 Listeners

Al Jazeera News Updates by Al Jazeera

Al Jazeera News Updates

240 Listeners

The Take by Al Jazeera

The Take

478 Listeners

Al Jazeera Investigates by Al Jazeera

Al Jazeera Investigates

103 Listeners

The Bottom Line by Al Jazeera

The Bottom Line

31 Listeners

This Is Palestine by The Institute for Middle East Understanding

This Is Palestine

398 Listeners

Hindsight by Al Jazeera

Hindsight

80 Listeners

The Inside Story Podcast by Al Jazeera

The Inside Story Podcast

128 Listeners

Centre Stage by Al Jazeera Media Network

Centre Stage

0 Listeners

Necessary Tomorrows by Al Jazeera Media Network

Necessary Tomorrows

13 Listeners

The Chris Hedges Report by Chris Hedges

The Chris Hedges Report

245 Listeners

Now You Know by Al Jazeera

Now You Know

7 Listeners

True Crime Reports by Al Jazeera

True Crime Reports

23 Listeners