The tape starts rolling and Tommy James confesses that Toy Story should've ended as a trilogy.

That "lukewarm" take sends Tommy James and Mr. A-Town into a full ranking of the first four Toy Story films before reviewing Toy Story 5, debating emotional endings, unforgettable characters, and whether Pixar should've left it at Andy's story.

Plus, Alex uses his second Heartthrob question, and the mystery of "Dude! Where's Malave?" takes its first big moment as Mista Malave's first forgotten destination is finally revealed.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!

The tape starts rolling and Tommy James confesses that every Sunday night before school, he'd watch Wayne's World... followed by Spice World.

That confession launches the first You Only Get 10: Guilty Pleasure Movies, as Tommy and Matt each bring ten movies they're almost embarrassed to admit they love and fight to build the ultimate guilty pleasure box set.

Plus, "Dude! Where's Malave?" makes its debut, challenging listeners to help solve Mista Malave's foggy journeys, three souvenirs at a time.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!

The tape starts rolling and Mista Malave finally makes his long-awaited debut with a confession that proves his childhood obsession with Britney Spears may have gone just a little too far.

With A-Town away, Tommy James and Mista Malave aka. The Music Man expand Secret Mixtape Vol. 1 with five more guilty pleasure songs, defending forgotten favorites, revisiting pop classics, and debating which tracks deserve a place on the Deluxe Edition of the mixtape. Along the way, they rewind to the releases of Terminator 2: Judgment Day and Independence Day in "Where Were We When?"

Plus, the latest Heartthrob email finally catches Mista Malave up on everything he's missed, bringing him up to speed to solving the season-long mystery.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!

Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan kick off the first-ever Secret Mixtape, each bringing ten guilty pleasure songs to the table but with only ten spots available, every pick has to earn its place. Along the way, they debate what truly qualifies as a guilty pleasure, defend some questionable favorites, and try to build the ultimate nostalgic playlist.

Plus, "Where Were We When?" rewinds to June 28, 1997, another Heartthrob email delivers a brand-new clue, and the nostalgia keeps rolling.

Press play... because every mixtape tells a story.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!

Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan morph into the world of Mighty Morphin Power Rangers to revisit the franchise that helped define a generation. From unforgettable Rangers and iconic villains to the episodes that still hold up today, the guys debate what made the original series so special—and why some of its biggest creative decisions still spark arguments decades later.

Plus, "Where Were We When?" rewinds to the pop culture of 1993, another Heartthrob email delivers a new clue, and the nostalgia is at full power.

It's Morphin Time... press play.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!

Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan dive headfirst into the golden age of Nickelodeon game shows, revisiting the slime, the legends, and the unforgettable challenges that made kids dream of getting picked from the audience. From favorite hosts and iconic sets to the games they'd love to play today, the guys relive one of television's most chaotic eras.

Plus, "Where Were We When?" looks back at the pop culture of the time, another Heartthrob email delivers a new clue, and nostalgia is the biggest winner of the day.

Grab your orange helmet and press play.

Welcome to the very first episode of I Killed My Tamagotchi!

Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan take on one of the toughest nostalgic debates imaginable: ranking the greatest songs from the Disney Renaissance. From unforgettable ballads to show-stopping anthems, every pick is up for debate as they try to decide which classics truly deserve a place at the top.

Plus, "Where Were We When?" heads back to 1999 for Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me, the New York Knicks' Finals run, and yet another conversation about the Disney movie Tommy somehow still hasn't seen. The season-long Heartthrob mystery also begins with its very first clue.

So press play... because every tape starts with a confession.