Mysterious ashen bodies are climbing out of a legendary volcano in Iceland. Why do they look exactly like people? What does it all mean? Turns out, they could be horrifying reminders of the past or odes to overwrought writing. The team is really divided on this one. Also, the writer behind "The Ritual" has a new Netflix horror dropping this week.

Motion Picture Terror Scale: 1 (Marcus) / 4 (Melissa) / 3 Grady. Quality: 1 / 4 / 3 Enjoyment: 1 / 3 / 3