I wrote a short version of this in May, before I understood it. A few field notes, just me catching the reflexes as they fired. This is the long version. The one where I went looking for why.

I thought leaving would make me free faster.

That was the first thing I got wrong.

I thought once the beliefs came apart, the version of me built around them would come apart too. Read the books, trace the history, find the seams in the doctrine, and pull. If the belief came apart in my hands, the self would follow.

But a self don’t surrender that quick.

A self has habits. Reflexes. Attachments. Old rooms it still knows how to walk into with the lights off.

The belief was the first thing I questioned. The person it made me into took way longer to find.

I should say this is how it went for me, not how it goes for everybody. I know people who lost the feeling first. The body stopped showing up before the mind had an argument for why. They sat in the same pew and felt nothing where the certainty used to be, and the reading came after, almost like cleanup. For them the formation cracked and the belief fell in behind it. Mine went the other way. I won the argument years before my body got the memo. So when I say belief first, self second, I mean mine. The order ain’t a law. It’s just the one I lived.

Deconstructing a belief is a research project. You can do it at a desk. You can do it angry. You find out the verse you built your twenties on was a translation choice. The church councils I had been taught to treat like divine inevitability were rooms full of tired men who took a vote and went home, and the ones who lost the vote got a new name: heretic. The truth was whatever had the numbers that afternoon.

I’m not saying every person involved was lying. I’m saying the certainty was more human than I had been allowed to admit.

You feel betrayed. Then you feel free. Then you move on to the next brick.

It’s clean, at least next to what comes after. It got an ending. You can talk about it at a party and sound smart.

Deconstructing a self is a different animal. Nobody warned me about that part. Or maybe they did, and I was too busy enjoying the clarity to hear them.

Here’s what I mean. The belief was just the top layer. What I didn’t understand then was that the belief never stayed in my head. It trained my instincts. It organized my whole sense of danger, love, obedience, belonging, shame, and safety.

And I ain’t even saying all of it came from church. Some of this just Black survival too. You learn to read a room before you can read a book. You learn to stay understandable. You learn to tuck certain parts of yourself away so don’t nobody punish you for being too much, too loud, too sexual, too angry, too honest. Church gave it scripture. The world gave it consequences. By the time I was grown I couldn’t tell you where one stopped and the other started. They had both been teaching the same lesson: make yourself easy to keep.

Underneath the belief was a body that learned how to stand when worship started. Underneath that was a reflex that flinched at certain words. Underneath that was a way of loving people with conditions baked in I never chose. Underneath that was a version of me that only knew how to feel okay when somebody above me was pleased.

You can delete the doctrine in an afternoon. The body keep the appointment.

I noticed it the first time somebody disagreed with me and my body reacted like I had sinned. Not like I had been misunderstood. Not like we just saw it different. My face went hot. My ears actually rang. I felt my shoulders climb toward my neck and my hands go cold, and there was that drop in my stomach like the second before you get caught. The man across from me was just making a point. My body was bracing to get corrected in front of a room that had been empty three years.

That’s when I started to understand. The church can leave before the formation does. You can stop attending and still carry its reflexes into every room you walk in.

I left the building in 2021. I’m still finding rooms in myself with the lights on and somebody I used to be still sitting in them.

Because when you take the belief out, you don’t get a clean empty space where a free man walks in. You get a hole shaped exactly like the thing you removed, and everything around it still leaning toward where it used to be.

The trust I handed out too easy. The certainty I performed when I was scared. The way I turned being useful into rent. The way I tried to become smaller than whatever was about to judge me.

None of that was theology. It was formation. It was what the theology trained in me, and what the world co-signed.

For a while I thought I was free because I didn’t believe the old answers no more. But I still needed permission the same way. I still confused disagreement with danger. I still said yes with my mouth while my body was already leaving the room. I still tried to earn rest, earn love, earn belonging, earn the right to not be a problem.

That was humiliating to admit. I wanted to believe I was free because I had new language. Really I just had new language over the same old fear. I could reject the whole theology and still act like somebody’s approval was oxygen, and hating that I did it ain’t change the fact that I did.

I didn’t want healing. I wanted proof that leaving had already made me whole. Because that would mean I escaped the argument before I escaped the formation, and the argument was the only part I knew how to win.

And you grieve it. That’s the part I didn’t expect. You grieve the certainty even when you know it was a lie, because the lie still gave you somewhere to stand. You grieve the version of you that fit, even though fitting was killing you slow. You can be right about all of it and still cry in your car, which I did, in a Walgreens parking lot, over a conversation that hadn’t even gone bad.

I think I wanted deconstruction to be a debate I could win. It wasn’t. The debate was the warmup.

The real work been learning how to be a person without the thing that was holding me up. How to feel safe without somebody telling me I’m safe. How to love without needing somebody to confirm I’m allowed to exist. How to hear my own no after being built to say yes.

That take longer than reading, and it cost more than being right.

I’m not standing on the other side with a clean testimony about how I lost my religion and found myself. I’m still in it. Some days the old wiring fires and I catch myself performing for a room that ain’t there anymore, trying to make my pain legible enough to be believed, explaining a boundary like a defendant when all I had to do was say it like a man who’s allowed to have one.

And it ain’t always the church that pulls the trigger. Last month I was the only Black man in a meeting and I felt my voice go soft and reasonable before I even decided to talk. Watched myself round my own edges down in real time. Shrunk my hands. Smiled a half-second too long. No God in that room. No covering, no correction, no pulpit. Just an old part of me that learned a long time ago which version of me gets to leave a room safe. The church taught me to fear God. The world taught me to fear being misread. My body filed both under the same drawer and never asked me which was which.

That’s not failure. That’s just how long it takes to put down something your nervous system picked up before you could spell it.

So if you’re in the early part, where the ideas are falling and it feel sharp and clarifying and almost good, I don’t want to take that from you. That part matters. It just wasn’t the expensive part for me.

The self comes later.

People like to say bring water, like it’s a long hot trail and you’ll be tired but fine. I used to end it that way too. I don’t think it’s that. I think you bring water because you don’t know how far it is. Not because nobody made it. Because the ones who did kept walking, and ain’t circled back yet to tell you what’s out there.

Get full access to Amen. Aśe. And All That S**t. at amenaseandall.substack.com/subscribe