The modern Western story is that real knowledge comes from science or
careful reasoning, and anything else—the elder, the guru, the village
wise woman—is suspect. But science and reflection themselves rest on a
third, intuitive, embodied mode of knowing that we use constantly and
pretend we don’t. The doctor and the guru are running on the same
authority structure; the only difference is who’s allowed to wear the
coat. Which means we’re picking our sages by taste instead of
principle—and that’s how charlatans win.
Not sure what I’ve got against linen trousers in this episode. Quite
Further reading
In praise of thesage
Thescientific ritual (lecture)
Mundanecults (lecture)
It’s not ‘just’ aplacebo
Usefulpharmacology
How some psychics usepsychology to screw you (Forer)
AIhallucination is just man-guessing
Moralblindspots
Successfulprophets
Everythingis ideology
Thecharismatic leader (Weber)
References
Aristotle, MetaphysicsJohn Dewey, Experienceand Nature
Richard Dawkins, TED:Militant atheism
Bertram Forer, Thefallacy of personal validation
Phenotypicdrug discovery
Yann Martel, Life ofPi