Originally Aired: March 15, 1959

Gunsmoke #362, "Incident at Indian Ford," finds Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester returning from Hayes City when they encounter a small cavalry detachment camped by the river. Led by the inexperienced Lieutenant Dick and seasoned Sergeant Cromwell, the patrol has just ransomed Mary Tabor from the Arapahoe Indians in exchange for a wagon full of trade goods, including guns and ammunition. The nervous lieutenant insists hostile Arapahoe have been following them for three days, waiting for a chance to recapture the woman. However, when Dillon scouts the perimeter, he discovers evidence of only a single Indian tracker, not a war party.

The situation grows more complex when Dillon speaks with Mary Tabor herself. The young woman expresses deep shame and fear about returning to Dodge City, worried about how townspeople will judge her after her captivity, even though she insists her treatment wasn't what people assume. As tension mounts between the cautious marshal and the distrustful lieutenant, Dillon must determine the true intentions of the lone Arapahoe following them and help Mary face her uncertain homecoming.