Episode Summary

In this episode, we start with a small moment — a child mentioning that they get to chew gum during the Illinois Assessment of Readiness — and follow it into a larger question:

How did high-stakes testing become such a routine part of school that it now feels inevitable?

Amy reflects on raising her own children inside a testing system she has studied, written about, and once administered as a classroom teacher. Drawing on her experience preparing third graders for their first standardized test, researching children’s experiences of testing, and later stepping away from that grade level, she examines how policy becomes classroom reality.

We explore how federal accountability systems made annual testing structural, why the 95% participation rule continues to shape school responses, how Illinois moved from IGAP and ISAT to PARCC and IAR, and why teachers and parents often experience these systems differently.

We close by asking what children learn when adults treat constructed systems as natural — and what it means to stay conscious inside them.

When high-stakes testing feels inevitable, what are children learning about systems, authority, and participation?

• High-stakes testing as policy, not inevitability

• The 95% participation rule under NCLB and ESSA

• Illinois testing history: IGAP, ISAT, PARCC, and IAR

• Teacher compliance, care, and professional survival

• Student identity and the emotional experience of testing

• Parent advocacy inside institutional systems

Practitioner & Teaching Perspectives

FairTest. National Center for Fair and Open Testing.https://fairtest.org

Illinois State Board of Education. Illinois Assessment of Readiness (IAR).https://www.isbe.net/iar 

Illinois State Board of Education. Assessment Overview.https://www.isbe.net/Pages/Assessment.aspx

Research Sources Referenced in the Episode

U.S. Department of Education. Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA).https://www.ed.gov/essa 

U.S. Department of Education. No Child Left Behind Act Overview.https://www.ed.gov/media/document/execsummpdf-4020.pdf 

Foundational Research & Further Reading

Schneider, M. K. (2015).Common Core Dilemma: Who Owns Our Schools? Teachers College Press. https://www.tcpress.com/common-core-dilemma-who-owns-our-schools-9780807756492

Gorlweski, A., Porfilio, B., Gorlewski, D. (2012).Using Standards and High-Stakes Testing for Students: Exploiting Power with Critical Pedagogy https://www.peterlang.com/document/1109148 

Neill, M. (2016).The Testing Resistance and Reform Movement https://monthlyreview.org/articles/the-testing-resistance-and-reform-movement/ 

Author Background & Related Scholarship

Kelly, A. L. (2019).The High Stakes of Testing: Exploring Student Voice and Standardized Assessment through Governmentality. Brill Sense.https://brill.com/display/title/61974

Kelly, A. L. (2021).A Guide to High-Stakes Standardized Testing in the United States: A Historical Overview. Brill Sense.https://brill.com/display/title/54596

Parents: Ask your child what they think the test is for — and what they think it says about them.

Teachers: Reflect on how testing season changes the tone of your classroom. What messages are students receiving about learning, success, and compliance?

Follow us on Instagram: @secondlookeducation

Listen on Spotify & Apple Podcasts| Watch on YouTube @secondlookeducation