The Fallacy of Inevitability: How Hungary’s Election Exposes MAGA’s Global Delusions

The Allure of Authoritarianism

In Hungary, the imminent parliamentary elections might be a turning point not only for the nation but also for the global right-wing movement. Viktor Orban, Hungary’s Prime Minister since 2010, has transformed the country into what has been described as an “illiberal democracy.” This model, characterized by elections without fairness and a state dominated by oligarchic control, has been a beacon for the American far right. Orban’s governance—marked by one-party rule and stringent social controls—has drawn admiration from figures like former U.S. President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance. Orban’s potential defeat in the upcoming elections could signify a critical blow to this authoritarian blueprint that has been idolized by certain factions within the GOP.

The MAGA Connection

The connection between the American far right and Orban is not merely ideological but actively cultivated. JD Vance’s recent participation in Orban’s campaign rallies underscores how intertwined these political narratives have become. Their mutual endorsement points to a larger pattern: the exportation of America’s political turmoil and its authoritarian tendencies to international platforms like Hungary. This political brotherhood reveals a shared commitment to what Timothy Snyder calls the “politics of eternity,” where leaders aim to remain in power indefinitely, fueled by a politics of grievance rather than governance.

Institutional Decay and Public Backlash

Under Orban’s rule, Hungary has seen not only a degradation of democratic norms but also a tangible decline in living standards and institutional integrity. This has been coupled with rampant corruption—an often inevitable outcome of centralized power unchecked by democratic safeguards. The recent child sex abuse scandal involving the country’s right-wing party and the subsequent public protests indicate a breaking point. These events reveal the vulnerability of Orban’s regime and suggest that the Hungarian public’s patience for autocratic governance is waning.

Misdirection and the Myth of Historical Inevitability

The narrative that leaders like Orban, Trump, and Vance are beyond the reach of historical forces is a key facet of their political persona. This myth of historical inevitability serves to justify their actions and to insulate them from the consequences. However, the potential defeat of Orban could shatter this narrative, exposing the fallibility of their authoritarian model. It challenges the notion that there is a unidirectional flow of history leaning towards authoritarianism, revealing it instead as a manipulable construct used by these leaders to cement their power.

Concluding Insight: Democracy’s Resilience

The unfolding events in Hungary offer a critical lesson on the resilience of democracy. They remind us that despite efforts to erode democratic structures, the power of the vote remains an undeniable force that can disrupt even the most entrenched authoritarian regimes. This scenario not only highlights the internal contradictions of the MAGA and similar movements but also underscores the potential for democratic renewal through public dissent and electoral engagement. As Hungary teeters on the edge of significant political change, it serves as a potent reminder that history is not owned by any single leader or ideology—it is continually written by the actions of the people.

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit paulstsmith.substack.com