This week on Pic Six, Brad Gilmore and Jeff Smith dive deep—literally—into the 2005 tropical thriller Into the Blue, starring Paul Walker, Jessica Alba, Scott Caan, and Josh Brolin.What starts as a sun-soaked adventure off the coast of the Bahamas turns into a high-stakes mix of treasure hunting, temptation, and trouble, as a group of divers stumble across both a legendary shipwreck and a downed plane full of cocaine.

We talk about the film’s perfect blend of early-2000s style, Walker and Alba’s undeniable chemistry, and how this movie walked the line between beach fantasy and crime thriller.Plus, Brad and Jeff rank their favorite underwater movies, debate the “most 2000s” element of Into the Blue, and answer the big question: Was this movie secretly better than anyone gave it credit for?Grab your flippers, hit play, and join us for an episode that’s all sunshine, suspense, and saltwater.