The guys completed a Buffalo Trace Tournament a few months ago and there was a pretty large upset. Buffalo Trace Bourbon knocked off Elmer T. Lee in a shocking and convincing blind win.

But, was it the right decision? Tonight, we review Elmer T. Lee with friend of the show, Joe Decadence! We'll rate it based on its nose, taste, cohesiveness/complexity, and value!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices