The Elephant Island Chronicles

Presents

Is It Fantasy?

The 2nd in the Dreaming by Blondie inspired anthology

By Gio Marron

Narration by Amazon Polly

Is It Fantasy?

Myra watched the rain streak down the diner's windows, painting the world outside in blurred hues of gray. Inside, the buzz of the neon sign flickered against the chrome counter, casting soft, pulsating glows that matched the steady rhythm of her boredom. The late shift had an uncanny way of dragging time into a slow, syrupy crawl, every tick of the clock stretching out into an eternity. She wiped down the counter again, not because it needed it, but because it gave her something to do.

She was just about to refill her coffee when the door chimed. In walked a man, soaked to the bone, hair plastered to his forehead. He wasn’t the usual late-night crowd: no bleary-eyed truckers or shadowy loners seeking refuge from the cold. He had an air of detachment as if he’d stepped straight out of a different time or place and found himself in this greasy spoon diner inexplicably.

Myra’s first thought was that he looked like trouble—the kind that drifts in with the storm and leaves behind a mess. He took a seat at the counter without a word, his eyes lingering on the menu as if reading it could unlock some hidden truth. She slid over, coffee pot in hand.

“Rough night?” she asked, pouring him a cup.

He glanced up, a half-smile tugging at the corner of his lips. “You could say that. This place always this lively?”

“Only on the nights when the rain washes in the dreamers and the lost souls,” she replied, her voice laced with irony.

He laughed, a low, raspy sound that seemed to echo in the empty diner. “Lucky me.”

Myra liked him instantly. Not in a romantic way, but in the way you recognize a kindred spirit lost in the same fog of routine and quiet despair. His name was Ian, and he had a way of speaking that made even mundane topics like movies or books seem urgent, like secrets shared at midnight between lifelong friends.

“You ever think about leaving this place?” Ian asked after a while, stirring sugar into his coffee.

Myra shrugged. “Every day. But dreams are free, right? Doesn’t cost anything to imagine being somewhere else.”

He nodded thoughtfully. “Dreams are free, sure. But that’s just it—sometimes they’re all you get.”

There was a weight to his words, a hint of bitterness that clung to the air like the smell of stale grease. Myra wanted to ask more, to pry into the story behind his eyes, but the diner door swung open, admitting a blast of cold air and another faceless customer. She returned to her duties but kept glancing at Ian, her curiosity burning like a slow ember.

Later, after the last of the night’s stragglers had left and the diner was closed, Myra walked home under the dim streetlights, her thoughts still circling around Ian’s cryptic words. Her apartment was a small, cluttered space above a laundromat, filled with unfinished paintings, sketchbooks, and a sense of life on hold. She set her keys on the counter, kicked off her shoes, and collapsed onto the couch.

That night, as she drifted into sleep, her dreams picked up where her mind had left off. She found herself in a vast, sunlit landscape—golden fields stretching endlessly beneath a sky painted in hues of lavender and pink. Ian was there, standing at the edge of a cliff, looking out over a shimmering ocean. It was a scene that felt pulled from the pages of some forgotten storybook, a place where time didn’t matter and reality was a distant memory.

“Nice view,” she said, walking up beside him.

He turned to her, his expression unreadable. “Better than the diner, right?”

She laughed, a sound that echoed like bells across the dreamscape. “Anything’s better than the diner.”

They sat on the cliff’s edge, feet dangling over the abyss, talking about everything and nothing. Ian told her about the places he’d been, the lives he’d lived, and the countless roads that had led him to this moment. In dreams, it all made sense; the details were fluid, shifting like the tides, and Myra didn’t question the logic of it. She just listened, soaking in the warmth of the sun on her face and the feeling of being truly free.

When she woke the following day, the memory of the dream lingered, vivid and sharp like the aftertaste of strong coffee. She found herself thinking of Ian throughout the day, replaying their conversations as she served customers and cleaned tables. It was as if the dream had imprinted itself on her reality, a subtle shift that made the mundane world around her seem a little less concrete.

As days turned into weeks, Myra and Ian’s encounters became a regular rhythm, a secret pattern woven into her otherwise predictable life. Sometimes, he would show up at the diner, always around the same time, and they would talk like old friends reunited. Other times, he wouldn’t appear in person but instead find her in dreams, where their adventures continued unabated.

Myra began to notice the oddities—the way Ian always seemed to know exactly what she was thinking, the way he could manipulate the fabric of their shared dreams with a mere thought. It was as if he was more than just a figment of her imagination; he was more than a chance encounter at a diner. He was a catalyst, a mirror reflecting her own unspoken desires back at her.

One night, after a particularly vivid dream in which they had explored an ancient, crumbling city bathed in moonlight, Myra decided to confront him. They were sitting on the steps of a grand cathedral, the stone beneath them cool and worn smooth by centuries of footsteps.

“Who are you, really?” she asked, her voice barely a whisper against the stillness of the dream.

Ian looked at her, his expression serious for the first time. “Does it matter?”

“Yes,” she insisted. “It does. You’re in my dreams, you’re in my life, but I don’t even know if you’re real.”

He sighed, leaning back against the stone steps. “I’m as real as you want me to be. That’s the thing about dreams—they can be whatever you need them to be.”

Myra frowned, frustration bubbling up inside her. “But what if I want more than just dreams? What if I want something real, something tangible?”

Ian met her gaze, his eyes filled with an unfathomable sadness. “Then you have to decide what’s real to you. Is it this? Or is it the life you keep running away from?”

The dream dissolved around them, the city crumbling into dust, and Myra woke with a start, her heart racing. She lay in bed, staring at the ceiling, Ian’s words echoing in her mind. What was real? The dreams, with their boundless possibilities and uncharted territories, or the drudgery of her waking life, with its repetitive cycles and unanswered questions?

The next time Myra saw Ian, he was waiting for her outside the diner, leaning against the rain-slicked wall like he belonged there. She’d just finished her shift, and the city was drenched in a misty haze, the lights reflecting off the wet pavement in a kaleidoscope of color.

“Let’s go for a walk,” he said without preamble.

She hesitated, glancing back at the diner, but something in his voice pulled her forward. They wandered the streets in silence at first, the only sound the soft patter of rain against their coats. The city seemed almost magical in the half-light, the mundane transformed by the shimmering veil of rain.

“I’ve been thinking about what you said,” Ian finally broke the silence, his tone thoughtful. “About wanting something real.”

Myra nodded, hugging her coat tighter around herself. “Yeah. I just… I don’t want to waste my life chasing fantasies.”

He stopped walking, turning to face her. “What if I told you we could make our dreams real? That we could live them, not just in sleep but every day?”

She stared at him, searching his face for a hint of a joke, but he was serious. “What do you mean?”

“Let’s make a pact,” he said, his voice low and earnest. “Let’s live as if our dreams are real. No more just getting by—let’s actually go after what we want. Even if it’s just for a little while.”

Myra’s mind raced. The idea was ludicrous, impossible even, but it was also tantalizing. She’d spent so much of her life on the sidelines, dreaming of a world beyond her reach. And here was Ian, offering her a way to step into that world, to bridge the gap between fantasy and reality.

“Okay,” she said, her voice steady. “Let’s do it.”

She quit her job at the diner, pouring her energy into her art—paintings that captured the vivid landscapes of her dreams, sculptures that embodied the emotions she could never quite articulate. She spent her days exploring the city, seeking inspiration in its hidden corners and forgotten alleyways. Ian was always there, a constant presence at the edge of her vision, guiding her steps.

But as Myra’s dreams started to bleed into her waking life, she struggled to separate the two worlds. She would lose track of time, forgetting whether she was awake or asleep, whether the conversations she had with Ian were real or just figments of her imagination. It was exhilarating and terrifying, a dance on the razor’s edge between reality and fantasy.

One night, Ian appeared beside her as she worked on a new piece—a swirling, chaotic blend of colors that seemed to pulse with its inner light. He didn’t say anything at first; he just watched as she worked, his expression unreadable.

“This is amazing,” he said, his voice tinged with awe.

Myra stepped back, wiping her hands on her apron. “Thanks. I just… I don’t know. It feels like it’s coming from somewhere else, right? Like I’m just the conduit.”

Ian nodded. “You’re creating something real out of your dreams. That’s powerful.”

She smiled, but there was a flicker of doubt in her eyes. “But is it enough? Am I just fooling myself?”

Ian turned to face her, his gaze intense. “Only you can answer that. But remember, dreams are the blueprint. It’s up to you to build something tangible out of them.”

Myra looked at the painting, its colors shifting and blending like a living organism. It was beautiful but fleeting—just a moment captured in time, destined to fade. She wondered if her newfound reality was the same, a fragile construct built on the shifting sands of her imagination.

As the days wore on, Myra’s grip on reality became increasingly tenuous. She would wake up in the middle of the night, unsure of where she was, her dreams bleeding into the dark corners of her apartment. She began questioning everything—her art, decisions, and even her identity. It was as if the walls of her mind were closing in, trapping her in a never-ending loop of uncertainty.

One night, in a particularly vivid dream, she found herself back at the cathedral with Ian. This time, the city around them was in ruins, the grand structures crumbling into dust, the sky dark and foreboding.

“I think I’m losing my mind,” she confessed, her voice trembling. “I don’t know what’s real anymore.”

Ian watched her, his expression unreadable. “Maybe that’s because you’ve been looking in the wrong place.”

“What do you mean?”

He gestured to the ruins around them. “You’ve been trying to build something out of nothing. Your dreams are just that—dreams. They can guide you, inspire you, but they’re not meant to be lived in.”

Myra felt a surge of frustration. “But you told me to live as if my dreams were real. You made me believe—”

“I never made you do anything,” Ian interrupted gently. “You chose this path. You wanted an escape, and I was just a convenient way out.”

She stared at him, the realization hitting her like a punch to the gut. He was right. She’d been running from her life, using dreams as a crutch to avoid the hard truths she didn’t want to face. And now, standing in the midst of a crumbling dreamscape, she understood that she had been her own worst enemy.

“So what now?” she asked, her voice barely audible.

Ian stepped closer, his expression softening. “Now, you wake up. You face your life not as something to escape from but as something to shape with the same creativity you’ve poured into your dreams.”

Myra nodded, a flicker of determination sparking in her chest. She took a deep breath, closing her eyes, and when she opened them, she was back in her apartment, the early morning light filtering through the curtains. For the first time in a long while, the air felt clear, the world sharp and in focus.

Myra spent the next few days untangling the threads of her life, piecing together a new path that honored her dreams and reality. She returned to the diner, not as an employee but as an observer. She watched the people around her—the regulars, the strangers passing through, the staff who moved with a familiar rhythm. She saw the beauty in the small, mundane moments, the way a smile could light up a tired face, the quiet comfort of a shared cup of coffee.

She also dove back into her art, but this time with a different focus. She painted not just the fantastical landscapes of her dreams but also the everyday scenes she encountered—the graffiti-covered walls of the alleyways, the silhouettes of people huddled under umbrellas, the fleeting expressions of passersby lost in their own thoughts. Her work became a bridge between the real and the imagined, a testament to the power of seeing beauty in both.

One afternoon, while sketching by the river, Myra saw Ian in the crowd—a fleeting figure half-hidden by the throng of people. He caught her eye and gave her a small, knowing nod before disappearing into the bustle of the city. She didn’t chase after him; she didn’t need to. Whether he had been real or just a creation of her mind no longer mattered. What mattered was that she had found her way back to herself.

As the weeks passed, Myra continued to explore her new reality with a sense of wonder and curiosity. She traveled to parts of the city she’d never seen before, striking up conversations with strangers seeking new experiences that pushed her out of her comfort zone. She no longer relied on dreams as a refuge; instead, she used them as a guide to tap into her deepest desires and bring them to life.

One day, she decided to host a small art show in her apartment, inviting friends, neighbors, and even some of the regulars from the diner. She hung her paintings and sketches on the walls, displaying the dreamscapes and the pieces that captured the heart of the city she loved. The night was filled with laughter, conversation, and a sense of community that warmed her from the inside out.

Myra felt a profound sense of contentment as she looked around the room. For the first time in a long time, she wasn’t searching for something else, something more. She had found pleasure not in her dreams' grand, unattainable fantasies but in the simple, tangible moments of her waking life.

She realized that true pleasure wasn’t about escaping reality or chasing after an idealized version of life. It was about embracing the messiness, the imperfections, and the fleeting joys that made up the fabric of her existence. It was about living fully, with eyes wide open, and finding beauty in the here and now.

Myra sat by the river again, her sketchbook on her lap. The sun was setting, casting a warm glow over the water, and the city hummed with the sound of life all around her. She glanced at the faces of the people passing by, capturing their expressions with quick, deft strokes of her pencil.

She paused for a moment, closing her eyes and letting the sounds of the city wash over her. In her mind, she saw a familiar landscape—golden fields, a lavender sky, and the faint silhouette of Ian standing at the edge of a cliff. But this time, the dream didn’t feel like a separate world; it felt like an extension of the one she was in, a reminder that the boundaries between reality and fantasy are not as rigid as they once seemed.

Myra opened her eyes, taking in the vibrant tapestry of life around her. She smiled, feeling a sense of peace and purpose she had once only found in her dreams. With a renewed sense of determination, she picked up her pencil and began to draw, sketching a new dream that blended the real with the imagined, the tangible with the intangible, and the mundane with the extraordinary.

As the sun dipped below the horizon, she knew she would continue to dream, but now, she will do so with her eyes wide open, fully present in the world she created for herself. She will build her golden roads not in her sleep but in her waking hours, one step at a time, and she will find pleasure not in the escape but in the journey itself.

The bell above the diner’s door rang sharply, slicing through the quiet hum of the late-night shift. Maya flinched, her grip on the coffee pot tightening reflexively as the sudden noise snapped her out of her thoughts. The chime’s abruptness reverberated in the empty space, echoing off the chrome and linoleum, and for a moment, Maya’s heart raced, her mind struggling to catch up with the present.

She glanced toward the door, half-expecting something out of the ordinary, but it was just another customer—a man soaked from the rain, shaking droplets from his coat and hair. He moved with a casual ease, unaware of the small startle he had caused. Maya exhaled, forcing her pulse to slow, and turned her attention back to the task at hand.

But the bell’s ring had been jarring, a sharp pull back to reality that reminded her of where she was: a diner on a rainy night, serving strangers coffee and waiting for something—anything—to change.

The End.

From all of us here at the Elephant Island Chronicles, we hope you have enjoyed this original short story by Gio Marron. Until next time, stay curious.

Get full access to The Elephant Island Chronicles at giomarron.substack.com/subscribe