A row is erupting over the cost of criminal legal aid — and it’s about far more than legal fees. The State spent more than €115 million on criminal legal aid last year, a jump of over a third, even though case numbers fell. Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan wants to scrap the current payment system in the District Court and replace it with a flat fee per client. He says it will simplify things and speed up cases. 

Critics warn it could drive experienced defence lawyers out of the system and risks cutting corners on justice. Recent figures showing 31 lawyers earning over half a million euros each from legal aid have only intensified the debate. Meanwhile, Aontú’s Paul Lawless argues that repeat offenders on social welfare should contribute towards their defence costs. 

So, is reform overdue — or a threat to basic rights? 

Ciara Doherty is joined on the podcast today by defence solicitor Frank Buttimer and Mayo TD Paul Lawless.