Israel's Supreme Court has nullified a controversial judicial reform passed in July of 2023 that aimed to limit the court's power in overturning laws deemed unconstitutional. The reform, known as the "reasonableness" bill, faced widespread opposition, triggering nationwide protests. Critics of the reform argued that the law severely undermined the country's democracy by weakening the judicial system, making it difficult, if not impossible, for courts to challenge state rulings it deemed “extremely unreasonable”.

The Supreme Court's decision to strike down the law follows months of internal turmoil and reflects concerns about potential damage to the democratic characteristics of Israel. The ruling is a setback for the Netanyahu government's broader series of judicial reforms, which included attempts to increase government power over appointing judges and reduce the Supreme Court's oversight capabilities.

Remnant Response

The Bible does not promote a single form of government over another. However, it does promote justice, accountability, equality, and the rule of law (1 Samuel 8:1-20; Leviticus 19:15, Deuteronomy 17:18-20). We believe that every nation would be best suited to be led by men who have memorized this law (Joshua 1:8), and dedicated their lives to its full and complete execution. It is long past time for us to repent for our lack of abiding by the book of the law (2 Kings 22:8-13).

The law should be dedicated to promoting justice and the flourishing of mankind. Any attempt to prioritize the self-interest of rulers at the expense of the vulnerable in society will lead to judgment upon and suffering in a land (Isaiah 10:1-3).

We wrote a response to the Reasonableness Bill being passed on July 26, 2023, you can read it in full here.

By Kirby Mankin