On a quiet spring afternoon in 2005, Ray Gricar walked out of his office in Centre County and told no one exactly where he was going — only that he needed a drive.

By nightfall, he was gone.

The next morning, his red Mini Cooper sat abandoned in a parking lot near the slow-moving waters of the Susquehanna River in Lewisburg.  His phone was inside.  His keys were missing.  And the man who had built a career on solving other people's crimes had seemingly vanished without leaving a single clue behind.
Weeks passed.  Then something surfaced from the river — something that raised more questions than it answered.

Was this a carefully planned disappearance?  A desperate decision?  Or did someone finally catch up to a prosecutor who had made powerful enemies over decades in court?

As rumors swirl and theories collide, one thing remains certain: a seasoned district attorney stepped out for a drive… and never came home.

Support the show