Jennifer Cave's disappearance in 2005 in Austin, Texas, led to a global search for disturbed individual Colton Pitonyak. Jennifer, a finance student, had a strong friendship with Colton, a devout Christian from Arkansas. After a failed relationship, Jennifer found herself with Colton, who was arrested for drug possession and alcoholism. Jennifer's body was found in her apartment, with a shot to the chest as the cause of death. Colton maintained a not-guilty plea, claiming he had no memory of the events and was under the influence of drugs and alcohol. Laura, a close friend of Colton, was found guilty of tampering with evidence and delaying an attempt to catch a suspect.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices