In this intriguing episode of Gunsmoke, Marshal Matt Dillon encounters Joe Phy, a self-proclaimed U.S. Marshal, ruling the town of Elkader with intimidation and reputation. Phy’s control over the town is built on a foundation of fear, but Matt quickly realizes that something doesn’t add up. When it becomes clear that Phy is an imposter with no real authority, Matt devises a clever plan to expose the fraud.

With the help of local layabout Cicero Grimes, Matt orchestrates a showdown that forces Phy to reveal his cowardice. Meanwhile, the actual fugitive Matt was pursuing, the dangerous Kerry Post, reappears, leading to a tense but calculated arrest. In the end, Phy leaves town in disgrace, and Matt reflects on how even deception can sometimes lead to order—albeit temporarily.

This episode explores themes of authority, fear, and the resilience of truth, punctuated by moments of humor and suspense.

Keywords: "Gunsmoke Joe Phy episode," "August 1954 Gunsmoke radio," "Matt Dillon exposes fraud," "Elkader law and deception," "Cicero Grimes showdown," "Kerry Post fugitive arrest," "classic Western radio drama."

Cast: William Conrad, Parley Baer, Howard McNear, Georgia Ellis, Ralph Moody, Vic Perrin, John Dehner.