Jim is joined by the creator of MLB Daily Dingers, Matt Musico, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB shortstop José Reyes. First, Jim and Matt discuss Reyes' legacy with the New York Mets (7:12). Next, they cover a single-season hitting feat Reyes accomplished in 2006 that has never been repeated and how elite the triple and stolen base totals Reyes recorded really were (15:59). Finally, they rank Reyes among the best shortstop of the 21st Century (39:07), before making a final call on whether or not Reyes deserves to be inducted into Cooperstown (49:57).