Spongebob Squarepants was far from a sure thing when animator Stephen Hillenburg pitched him to Nickelodeon executives, but the program quickly became a gigantic hit that transformed the network, the children's television landscape, and the millions of kids who watched the show religiously. Combining well-defined characters with absurdist humor, vaudevillian gags, and a surreal reality, Spongebob inspired and enchanted a legion of children and adults.

Ryan was never really swept up in the Spongebob fandom, so he brought on Rachel and Riley to discuss how the show impacted them so deeply. Several core stories from Spongebob's first three seasons are discussed alongside an overview of the program's development and creative process. Discussion topics include Spongebob's connection to early Nicktoon Rocko's Modern Life, its spiritual debts to the Golden Age of Theatrical Animation, how perceptions of characters like Squidward and Patrick can change as one grows older, and why the first three seasons of Spongebob are far more revered than what came afterwards.