Mormon Folk Magic, Joseph Smith’s Occult Reputation & Dave Butler’s Cunning Man The hosts discuss ongoing interest in Joseph Smith’s seer stones, treasure digging, and whether these practices should be labeled “occult,” referencing questions from the FAIR Conference and Mark Ashurst-McGee’s work on Joseph as a “village seer.” Dave Butler introduces his novel series Cunning Man, co-written with Aaron Ritchie, about Hiram Woolley, a very Mormon sugar beet farmer in 1935 Utah who battles literal and figurative demons of the Great Depression using his Grandma Hetty’s documentable folk-prayer lore, alongside his adopted Navajo son Michael. They explore definitions of magic and “occult” as “hidden,” Christian grimoires like Hohman’s The Long Lost Friend, Catholic folk practices (including burying St. Joseph statues), sympathetic magic, and LDS garment folklore as both symbolic and protective, including how such beliefs appear in Mormon history and culture.
00:00 Occult Joseph Smith
02:02 FAIR Conference Questions
04:26 Cunning Man Series
06:20 Mormon Indiana Jones
10:59 American Paladin Hiram
16:23 Grimoires and Psalm Magic
17:37 Catholic Folk Practices
21:36 Defining Magic and Occult
27:40 Saint Joseph House Spell
31:44 Sympathetic Magic Explained
33:32 Magic Underwear Folklore
38:30 Garment Protection Lore
40:06 Carthage Jail Accounts
42:21 Charm Versus Blessing
43:46 Chi Rho Stand In
46:59 Decline of Magic
50:26 Cunning Man Trilogy
10:59 Bautista and Mexico
58:23 AUB and Fundamentalists
01:01:20 Future Books Ideas
01:04:29 Hofmann and Folk Magic
01:06:43 Wrap Up and Recommendations