Gauteng Education MEC Panyaza Lesufi has appealed to private schools to follow the Department of Basic Education's directive that schools reopen on 15 February, as allowing pupils to return earlier could potentially place a huge strain on the province's health system.

Schools were due to open on 27 January. Some independent schools opened last week, but the majority were due to reopen on Monday.

Following consultations with education stakeholders, including teacher unions, school governing bodies and independent schools' associations, the National Coronavirus Command Council (NCCC), Cabinet and the Council of Education Ministers (CEM) decided to delay the reopening, especially since the new variant of the virus in South Africa was said to affect young people.

Making the announcement during a media briefing in Pretoria on Friday, Basic Education Deputy Minister Reginah Mhaule said the decision was taken to give relief to the health system, which was already not coping due to the high number of Covid-19 cases.

But while many independent schools decided to turn to online learning after the opening of schools was postponed, at least one private school in Johannesburg seemed to be an outlier.

Helpmekaar Kollege in Braamfontein, Johannesburg, sent a newsletter to parents that all 1 200 pupils should report to school on Monday. In addition, a concert for Grade 8 pupils had been planned for Friday, 22 January, and a choir camp for Saturday and Sunday, 23 and 24 January.

But on Sunday, in an amended notice, Helpmekaar – or Helpies, as it is affectionately known among its pupils and staff – said it had decided to teach its pupils online from Wednesday, 20 January, according to its daily timetable (07:30 to 14:00).

"We want to be sensible in this peak period of Covid ahead and limiting people's risks," the school announced under the heading, "Helpies reconsiders", citing "the latest developments", among other considerations.

It stated that all learning will be presented online from Wednesday. In addition, all planned camps and activities have been postponed until further notice.

'We sensed danger'

Visiting the school on Monday, Lesufi – standing next to Helpmekaar's principal, Klaus König – said the school started its teaching activities last week, before Mhaule's announcement. But, having considered its options, the school had taken the decision to proceed with online learning.

"This weekend, I was flooded with reports that there are schools that believe they should go ahead with... reopening," Lesufi said during a brief media conference following his visit.

"We sensed danger and we felt that we can't just persuade the public education system – we need to also persuade the private education system.

"The reasons are simple. They are in the same communities, their parents are going to buy textbooks and school uniforms – they are going to be up and down. It's not about the capability of an institution to manage the virus, it's the movement, because the virus spreads through movement."

Lesufi added that he had come to learn about Helpmekaar's plans to reopen through the media and decided to engage the school's management to gauge its reasons.

However, König informed Lesufi that the school had since revised its schedule.

"As a leader, you revisit your own decision," Lesufi said.

Not an act of defiance

"The school was already open last week. The reopening was not [an act of] defiance. They had already opened. The decision [to postpone reopening] came late, and when the information was brought to [the school's] attention... they reconsidered [it] and they felt they should migrate to online learning."

Lesufi said the postponement came after the Gauteng Education Department wrote to Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga, citing concerns about an influx of the province's pupils from other provinces following the holidays.

"Hospital beds are full, both in private and public institutions. Many people ...