Today we go waaaay back in time to the first ever recorded murder trial in the United States...not first murder, just the first recorded one. If you enjoy musicals, you'll enjoy the Hamilton connection. Next, another two parter with the murder of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley...gotta love a two part episode. Our throwbacks are the infamous Gordon Gartrell shirt, the 90s Toronto Blue Jays, and velour sweat suits. Follow us on Instagram and write to us with your stories at [email protected].