In this very special Decasode of Lost the Script, the crew welcomes our very first guest, Mattie Giglio, as we make a pitch-black plot involving human sacrifice, fake cancer, and puppy-punchers (Did I mention this was a comedy?) Later on, we put on our reviewing pants as we leave the quarantine to trek through 1991's High Strung and wish we could Eternal Sunshine this one out of our heads.