This week we are covering a true crime case from the east coast of Florida, centered in the oldest city of the nation; one that is deemed to be one of the most haunted as well. Today we are talking about Athalia Lindsley and her refusal to be quieted- even after death.  

Book Recommendation: 

Murder in St. Augustine: The Mysterious Death of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley 

Sources & Reference Material: 

https://crimecapsule.com/bad-blood-the-murder-of-athalia-ponsell-lindsley/ 

https://www.truecrimeneversleeps.com/athalia-lindsley-the-florida-machete-murder/ 

https://prabook.com/web/athalia_ponsell.lindsley/2604824 

https://www.floridanewsline.com/ponte-vedra/pophistory-murder-in-saint-augustine/ 

https://ghostaugustine.com/blog/the-tragic-end-of-athalia-ponsell-lindsley-unsolved-mystery-in-the-ancient-city/