Sony's "Madam Web" has spun quite a web of controversy, and we're here to untangle it all. What happens when two film enthusiasts with vastly different takes on the same movie sit down to dissect it? Pure entertainment.

This conversation dives deep into Dakota Johnson's portrayal of Cassandra Webb, a paramedic who develops clairvoyant abilities and becomes entangled in protecting three young women from a mysterious villain with spider-like powers. We explore how the film seems trapped between eras – feeling more like an early 2000s superhero movie than a contemporary Marvel offering, complete with awkward dialogue, thin character motivations, and missed opportunities.

The marketing of "Madam Web" becomes a central point of contention as we discuss the bait-and-switch of promoting Sydney Sweeney and others in spider costumes that only appear briefly in a dream sequence. Is this legitimate promotional strategy or outright deception? We also examine how this film connects (or fails to connect) to the larger Spider-Man mythology, from Ben Parker's appearance to the mystical elements that feel at odds with Spider-Man's traditionally science-based origins.

Whether you're a die-hard Marvel fan trying to decide if this is worth your time, someone who's already seen it and wants perspective, or just enjoy hearing passionate film discourse, our spirited debate offers something for everyone. We even place "Madam Web" in the context of other critically panned superhero films – is it truly as disastrous as some critics claim, or merely an underwhelming B-movie experience? Listen and decide for yourself!

Subscribe to hear more of our takes on the latest superhero offerings, throwback film discussions, and deep dives into cinema classics. Your friendly neighborhood film critics are just getting started.

Support the show