This episode features Elijah McNally, Marketing Director at Arias Sanguinetti Trial Lawyers, a 20-attorney powerhouse that has recovered over $1.5 billion for its clients. Elijah offers a fresh perspective on legal marketing, emphasizing a move away from aggressive, jargon-filled advertising toward a "trauma-informed" and sincere approach. He explains how answering a potential client's questions directly and leading with empathy can build trust and, counterintuitively, achieve better results with SEO and AI. Elijah provides a playbook for firms of all sizes, from solos testing the waters with a $1,000/month Meta ads budget to larger firms learning how to vet and manage marketing vendors effectively. This conversation is a masterclass in modernizing your firm's outreach by focusing on the human story behind every case.

Show Notes:

(00:00) Introduction: Elijah McNally and the powerhouse firm, Arias Sanguinetti.

(00:56) A Fresh Perspective: Moving beyond "rinse and repeat" marketing to tell relatable stories.

(03:36) Trauma-Informed SEO: Answering direct client questions to build trust in sensitive practice areas.

(06:21) AI and SEO: How a client-first strategy is being rewarded by new technology.

(07:41) The "Chicken Recipe" Problem: Why direct answers are key to building trust and converting leads.

(10:14) Big Picture Strategy: A look at Arias Sanguinetti’s marketing channels, including SEO, social media, and paid Meta ads.

(12:07) Advice for Solo Attorneys: How to start marketing yourself and when to hire an expert.

(13:23) The $1,000/Month Experiment: How to test Meta ads effectively on a small budget.

(15:08) The Two-Month Rule: How long to run an ad campaign before deciding if it’s effective.

(19:58) Vetting Your Vendors: How to avoid "snake oil salesmen" and find partners aligned with your mission.

(22:11) Due Diligence Checklist: Talk to 10 vendors, check their work for typos, and ask for client references.

(23:41) Managing Your Agency: Why you must be the "squeaky wheel" to get the best results.

(25:54) Speaking Two Languages: Crafting different messages for attorney referrals (B2B) and potential clients (B2C).

(27:17) Cutting Through the Noise: How to strip away legalese and close the emotional gap with your audience.

(34:14) Tailoring the Message: Adjusting marketing strategies for different practice areas based on the client's emotional state.

(37:12) People-First Marketing: The story behind the "Women fighting for women" ad that generated a flood of leads.

(39:50) The Power of Sincerity: Why leading with your heart is the most effective and ethical marketing strategy.

Contact Elijah: [email protected] or on LinkedIn.

Want to join the show as a guest? Email us: [email protected]

Join our ⁠⁠⁠Facebook community⁠⁠⁠ to connect with other founding attorneys.

This podcast was brought to you by:

Legion: Actually reliable litigation drafting — at AI speed.

Tired of litigation busy work? Get court-ready pleadings, serve-ready discovery, and battle-ready motions — in 30 minutes or less.

Visit legion.law

Music: lofi type beat "flower market" by snoozy beats.