Molly and Katie bring in the big guns to tackle the scariest topic they've dealt with all season: dating in New York. Local funnyperson Caroline Pigott joins them with a bizarre tale of Hanukkah romance and intrigue. Katie goes off of ethical non-monogamy and Molly covers the 2014 Tinder murder mystery of Gable Tostee and Warienna Wright, which will leave you clutching your pearls or the pearls of the person nearest to you.