The Winter Dance is fast approaching and Mallie is dateless. Primarily because she’s waiting for her crush, Gorgeous Gary, to ask her to be his date. When the invitation doesn’t come, Mallie decides to take matters into her own hands. With the help of her friends, Mallie sets out to let Gary know that she’s waiting on him. But Mallie discovers that she’s not the only person who has an interest in Gorgeous Gary. Much to her chagrin, the other person happens to be her new arch rival, Tiffany Johnson.