In which the gentlemen of the Lowick circle debate the delicate and disagreeable matter of Dorothea’s late husband’s surprising codicil and its implications, with much concerned discussion about the presence of Mr. Ladislaw and the proprieties of protecting Dorothea’s reputation and welfare. As they deliberate the best course of action, themes of loyalty, suspicion, and social expectation entwine in the subdued atmosphere of mourning and uncertainty.