Three days before the murder, a woman walked into a Palm Beach costume shop with cash in hand and a peculiar shopping list: an orange wig, white face paint, and a clown suit. In Episode 4, we follow the shop owner's unforgettable memory, the matching balloons from a nearby supermarket, and the chilling detail that linked this purchase to the morning Marlene Warren was shot.

true crime, cold case, killer clown, Marlene Warren, Sheila Keen-Warren, Florida murder, podcast mini-series, costume shop clue