After a thrilling AL Wild Card Game, the guys discuss Buck Showalter's decision to not bring in one of the best closers in baseball. Rose and Millar debate five storylines from tonight's Giants and Mets NL Wild Card matchup and Millar lets a coin flip determine his winner. Brad Ausmus returning to the Tigers, Lucas Duda being left off the Wild Card roster or a magazine cover possibly jinxing the Cubs? The guys discuss which is intriguing and which is intriguing-er. It was the punch heard around the world! After a heated series earlier in the year between the Blue Jays and Rangers, will both clubs be able to keep their emotions in check heading into their ALDS matchup? Also, find out who wears their ball cap just a tad too tight on the latest edition of GOT HEEEEEM!