<p>There was something wrong with Brian Cohee—but it didn’t show in photographs. His smile was clean, his voice even, his future seemingly mundane. But somewhere behind his eyes, something ancient and unfeeling had taken root. In March 2021, that quiet horror slipped its mask. Authorities found the remains of Shane DeWitt scattered—cut, hidden, arranged—not by chaos, but by intention. Cohee didn’t flee, didn’t deny. He confessed with the calm of someone recounting a dream, as if murder were a curiosity he’d finally indulged after years of silent rehearsal. He had studied killers the way priests study scripture. What he wanted wasn’t death—it was dominion. And when he finally crossed that line, there was no remorse. Only the realization that the monster had been awake for a long time. And now it had a name.</p>

There was something wrong with Brian Cohee—but it didn’t show in photographs. His smile was clean, his voice even, his future seemingly mundane. But somewhere behind his eyes, something ancient and unfeeling had taken root. In March 2021, that quiet horror slipped its mask. Authorities found the remains of Shane DeWitt scattered—cut, hidden, arranged—not by chaos, but by intention. Cohee didn’t flee, didn’t deny. He confessed with the calm of someone recounting a dream, as if murder were a curiosity he’d finally indulged after years of silent rehearsal. He had studied killers the way priests study scripture. What he wanted wasn’t death—it was dominion. And when he finally crossed that line, there was no remorse. Only the realization that the monster had been awake for a long time. And now it had a name.

murderer-Brian Cohee

<div>Early on Wednesday.</div>
<div></div>
<div>That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams.</div>
<div></div>
<div>Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open.</div>
<div></div>
<div>But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark.</div>
<div></div>
<div>On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl.</div>
<div></div>
<div>Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.</div>

Religion & Spirituality

True Crime

Spirituality

History

Early on Wednesday. That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams. Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open. But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark. On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl. Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.

Early on Wednesday.

That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams.

Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open.

But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark.

On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl.

Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.

Share murderer-Brian Cohee

Sign up to save your podcasts

murderer-Brian Cohee

murderer-Brian Cohee

More shows like Early On Wednesday

William Ramsey Investigates

Codega's Codex of Curiosities

The Targeted Individual Podcast

The Hometown Horrors Podcast